Rorate Caeli

Cardinal Zen in action






More pictures of the Cardinal's "Missa Cantata" last December 27 can be found here.

Pictures of his Solemn Pontifical Mass on Easter 2009 can be found here.

I'm perfectly aware that bishops aren't supposed to do the "Missa Cantata" according to the rules of the classical Roman Rite, but really, in this situation, is it fair to overlook the Cardinal's willingness to offer the Traditional Latin Mass frequently? Keep in mind that he has actually volunteered to be part of the line up of priests who alternate in celebrating Hong Kong's Sunday TLM. To my knowledge, he is the only cardinal who frequently celebrates the TLM in a fixed site.

"On the Gathering of Anglicans"

Archbishop John Hepworth, primate of the Traditional Anglican Communion, has released an important pastoral letter, "On the Gathering of Anglicans," dated 20 Jan. 2010 and addressed to the bishops, clergy and lay faithful of the TAC, regarding the Apostolic Constitution Anglicanorum Coetibus and the TAC's request for full, corporate communion with the Catholic Church. The pastoral letter is published in its entirety at The Angl0-Catholic, and includes the petition the TAC had sent to the Holy See, requesting the Pope's fatherly guidance in bringing the members of the TAC into unambiguous unity with the Catholic Church in a way that would preserve that which is good in Anglican tradition. Below are just a few excerpts, including reflections of Archbishop Hepworth in which he gently calls on the TAC's bishops, priests, and deacons to submit to re-ordination, since that is what Rome will requires:

Our Petition

. . . It is fundamental to the life of the church that its bishops and the churches they lead be in Eucharistic Communion with the See of Rome to which bishops of the ancient church looked as the instrument of unity and Catholic authenticity.

. . . The fullest statement of contemporary Christian belief, the bishops [of the TAC] believe, is to be found in the Catechism of the Catholic Church. It is deeply biblical and patristic, and addresses matters that puzzle and confront Christians at the present moment. The bishops understand that not everything in the Catechism is of equal authority, and also understand that the faith must be proclaimed to every generation in language that accurately portrays what the Church has received. Therefore they acknowledge that the Catechism is the most complete and authentic expression and application of the Catholic faith in this moment of time, and that they signed a copy on the altar as attesting to the faith they aspire to teach and hold. None of the bishops would claim to understand every aspect of the faith with perfection, and none would claim to teach perfectly at all times. But they do claim to aspire to teach and to hold the faith that is set forth in the Catechism. . . .

The Standard of Belief

. . . Many members of our community have been using the Catechism as a reference and a sourcebook for years. Its language is contemporary and its methodology, based on the Scriptures, the Fathers of the Church, and the liturgical Creeds, is already familiar to Anglicans.

Many of the things being denied at this moment in the world have been taken for granted for centuries. The nature of God, the revelation of God in Christ, the nature of holy scripture, the authority of Christian moral teaching about life and sexuality, the attack on the nature of marriage, and the widespread abandonment of holiness of life (especially among some of those consecrated to religious and priestly life), have all posed enormous problems for those who seek to teach and understand the Christian faith. The Catechism is a contemporary document addressing contemporary problems of contemporary unbelief.

What of the re-ordination of clergy?

. . . Not only the ordination of women to all three sacred orders, but the redefining of the Anglican understanding of itself as part of the “Church Catholic” that the ordination of women has necessitated, has introduced more than grave doubt about the validity of any Anglican Communion ordinations. It is now difficult to determine whether any particular Anglican Bishop has any intention to do as the Church has always done, when he (or she) specifically intends to do that which the Church has never done. The almost complete elimination of what was once a dominant Anglo-Catholicism from many provinces of the Anglican Communion has removed the clearest statement of Catholic belief about Holy Orders from the Anglican consciousness.

. . . It is my wish, and I believe the wishes of my fellow bishops, that every deacon and priest in our Communion has a certainty of validity that rests, not on the winning of a theological argument, not on the best that was available at the time, but on the indisputable certainty of Catholic practice. I have said to a number of priests that when they are saying Mass in the crypt of St Peter’s on the tombs of the Apostles, I want them to be able to look to one side and the other and to know with absolute certainty that their priesthood has the same objective reality as the priesthood of those on either side.

Finally, I commend this development to your prayers and the deepest parts of your conscience. I believe with all my heart that this is a work of God and an act of great generosity by Pope Benedict. The Anglican tradition that we treasure will only survive, I believe, across the generations yet to come if it discovers the protection of apostolic authority. It is my cherished wish that each of us can stand at the altar with our fellow Christians and receive the same Eucharistic Christ. That is the ultimate test of unity. In the centuries since the church in the West became fractured there has been no offer such as the one that is now before us. For Anglicans, Unity has been a dream beyond reach. Now it is a dream that can be fulfilled. I understood when I became a member of the Traditional Anglican Communion (in a dark period of my life when it became impossible to practice my priesthood in a diocese about to ordain women) that this was a Communion heading towards a goal. It had separated from the Anglican Communion. Instead of drifting at the whim of wave and wind, it had chosen to head towards the only realistic destination, that from which Anglicans had separated centuries before. I was grasped by that vision of those who founded this Communion. We are now in the waves just beyond the harbour entrance. Pray God that we have the courage to enter and make our homes there.

Stating the obvious

Teofilo de Jesus of the blog "Vivificat" has posted his thoughts on the recently leaked outline for the Orthodox-Catholic Dialogue on Petrine Primacy. (The leakage of the draft text by Sandro Magister has been deplored by the Pontifical Council for Christian Unity.)

An excerpt:

Let me focus and simplify the question a bit: would the notion of papal authority as expressed during the First Vatican Council be compatible with the view of the Roman Primacy as exercised during the first millennium?

At this moment I don't see an answer that will satisfy both sides. If communion is restored on the basis of first millennium doctrines and canonical discipline, it will be logical to discard 1000 years of Latin self-understanding, dogmatics, and all of the ecumenical councils called for by the Pope - directly or indirectly, as in the case of Constance - that came to be after the schism. All those councils would be demoted to General Councils of Latin Christianity with no relevance to the East. The identity of the Catholic Church centered in Rome to be the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church of Christ will be undermined, and what our Church has adopted as dogmatic truths regarding ecclessiology would become open questions to be solved again with Eastern input.

If you think that the Lefevbrerist schism has been inopportune and bad enough, just imagine what will happen if the Latin Church approves reunion with the East under this terms.

I think that our side expects that an in depth study of the "development of dogma" will prove, if not beyond reasonable doubt, then to a degree of moral certainty, that the papacy as conceived in Vatican I is a true, positive development of Patristic Christianity. I can see the Orthodox already saying "no" to such a proposal. If they were to agree to such a proposal, their own claim to be Christ's One, Holy, Catholic, Church will be undermined, followed by their own identity crisis. I can tell you that the monks of Mt. Athos will not go along, and that integrist, non-canonical jurisdictions already existing in the Orthodox Church like the Greek Old Calendarists and the Russian Old Believers will see their ranks swell.

Once again, I want to temper down all the expectations that this agreement may give rise to. We're all hopeful of eventual reunion and I'm gratified that dialogue on very substantive questions has begun. But we're not any closer to reunion and, barring a miracle, I still don't expect to see it any time soon.

More on Cardinal Zen

A representative of the Tridentine Latin Mass Society of Hong Kong, which is based in the Salesian-run parish of Mary Help of Christians, has informed us that His Eminence Joseph Cardinal Zen SDB will offer the Traditional Latin Mass in that church on Easter Sunday, April 4, 2010, 12:30 P.M.

Cardinal Zen frequently celebrates the Traditional Mass for the Latin Mass Society of Hong Kong. His last public Mass as Ordinary of Hong Kong was a Solemn Pontifical Mass according to the 1962 Missal on Easter 2009. After that he celebrated the TLM on the Feast of the Ascension (celebrated on a Sunday, May 24, 2009), on the 4th, 7th and 13th Sundays after Pentecost, and on December 27, 2009 (as reported earlier on this blog).

The Summorum Pontificum Bishop?

Rorate Cæli continues to follow with interest the doings of Bishop Marc Aillet of the diocese of Bayonne in France. Pray that His Excellency is the prototype for French bishops who will restore the “eldest daughter of the Church” to her former glory.
Bordeaux: A bishop among the "trads"
BORDEAUX (Novopress): Mgr. Aillet, Bishop of the diocese of Bayonne, was in Bordeaux this weekend. He celebrated ordinations in the church of Saint-Eloi, personal parish of the Institute of the Good Shepherd. This visit constitutes a first for the former parish of Father Philip Laguérie, superior of the Institute and erstwhile pastor of St. Nicolas du Chardonnet in Paris while he was a member of the Society of Saint Pius X.
For the first time a sitting French bishop came to Saint-Eloi to celebrate Mass in the extraordinary form (in Latin with back to the people) and took the opportunity to meet members of the Institute which was erected as a "society of apostolic life" by the Vatican in 2006. The visit by Bishop Aillet, known for his strong positions on family values, is the first step of the dialogue that is developing between him and the Institute of the Good Shepherd.
Indeed, Bishop Aillet wishes to increase the number of Tridentine Masses in his diocese - he has even established a Latin Mass in Bayonne every Sunday - and he is relying on the establishment of religious communities dedicated to the Latin Mass to achieve this end. Will the Institute of the Good Shepherd benefit from this project by obtaining a parish on the Basque coast? The process seems to be under way.



Pontifical Liturgies

1) Messa in Latino now has pictures of the Solemn Pontifical Mass and Vespers celebrated by Archbishop Raymond Burke on January 24, 2010 in the parish of Artallo, in the Diocese of Albenga-Imperia. (This Mass had been announced by Rorate on January 15). Unfortunately, the Pontifical Mass of Cardinal Castrillon-Hoyos that Rorate announced alongside that of Archbishop Burke, and which had been scheduled for January 16, was canceled at the last minute.





2) A video with pictures from the Epiphany Pontifical Mass of Cardinal Castrillon-Hoyos can be found here:



3) Messa in Latino is also announcing that Angelo Cardinal Scola, Patriarch of Venice, will be assisting at a Mass to be offered by Fr. Konrad zu Loewenstein FSSP on Saturday, March 6, 2010, 5:30 P.M., at the Church of San Simon Piccolo in Venice.

TLM in Santa Croce

Some trusted friends of Rorate have informed us that in the Basilica of Sant'Apollinare in Rome, within the premises of the Pontifical University of Santa Croce (run by Opus Dei), the Traditional Latin Mass is now said three mornings a week (Monday to Wednesday) at one of the side altars.

Other priests have also said the TLM in the Basilica on occasion. To our knowledge, Santa Croce is currently the only Pontifical University in Rome that has Masses according to the Usus Antiquior, the daily and Sunday TLM in the Antonianum having been suppressed last year.


These Masses are not "regularly scheduled", these being private Masses. However, anyone can come in and attend.

Successor to a martyred Archbishop



Emil Shimoun Nona was consecrated bishop and installed as the new Chaldean Archbishop of Mosul on January 17, 2010.

The new Archbishop is 42 years old. He is the successor of the martyred Paulos Faraj Raho, killed by Islamic militants in 2008.

More pictures of the consecration and installation rites -- done according to the Chaldean Rite as it now stands -- can be found here.

H/t: ByzCath.

Pontifical Consecration of New Chapel of the Northern American FSSP Seminary with Cardinal Levada

From the New Liturgical Movement:


DENTON, Nebraska – January 22, 2010 – The Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter is pleased to announce the Pontifical Consecration of its newly built chapel at Our Lady of Guadalupe Seminary on Wednesday, March 3rd at 10:00am (CST). Bishop Fabian Bruskewitz will celebrate the Pontifical Consecration and Mass according to the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite.

The five hour ceremony will be held in the presence of a very special guest from the Vatican, William Cardinal Levada, Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. The Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter is delighted to have the presence of one of the highest ranking officials in the Catholic Church. Cardinal Levada's presence is connected with his position as President of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei established by Pope John Paul II and recently expanded by Pope Benedict XVI to facilitate the full incorporation into the life of the Church of communities and individuals attached to the Extraordinary Form.

Thanks to Thomas Gordon Smith, its architect, the seminary chapel reflects a contemporary rebirth in the rich tradition of classical Catholic architecture. Upon entering through its mahogany doors, the visitor will be immersed in the chapel's beauty and grandeur which include an elevated main altar, emphasized by a 31-foot marble canopy or “baldachino”, the chapel's seven side altars and liturgical choir stalls which seat 92 seminarians and priests. These are some of the integral qualities of this chapel which, on March 3rd, will be full of the people for which it was made.

The Pontifical Consecration and Mass is open to all of the public. Any and all the faithful are cordially invited and are most welcome to attend this joyful event and enjoy refreshments afterwards.

Due to the number of guests and limited space, rooms and television screens will be provided for those outside of the chapel who wish to participate.

The Pontifical Consecration and Mass will be televised live on the Eternal World Television Network (EWTN) at 11:00AM (EST). Watch the Pontifical Consecration and Mass Live Online!
www.ewtn.com/audiovideo

How Pope Benedict XVI is beginning to change Rome

From Valle Adurni:

I've been away in Rome, so I'm sorry that some of you have had to wait to have your comments put up.

Now our Holy Father has been several years in the job, it has been interesting to see how Rome has adjusted. Perhaps the clearest evidence is to be seen liturgically.

(Read more.)

First SSPX-Ecclesia Dei meeting in 2010

French religious news agency reports (source: Petrus) that the first meeting in 2010 between the representatives of the Holy See and those of the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Pius X (FSSPX / SSPX) took place yesterday. "We have started to deepen the themes of the agenda in the doctrinal talks".
______________
Recess till the end of January.

Update on the Canizares Interview

The New Theological Movement has now published the complete translation of the interview of Cardinal Canizares Llovera.

The older post on Rorate regarding the interview can be found here.

Confirmed: Léonard, Archbishop of Brussels

The Holy Father has accepted the resignation of Cardinal Daneels as Archbishop of Mechlin-Brussels, and has named Bishop André-Mutien Léonard, of Namur, as the new Archbishop.

A brave and excellent choice by the Pope. Let us hope it is not too late for the Church in the capital of the European Union.

"A propitious time to revive the ecumenical spirit"

Finally, I would like to note that tomorrow the traditional Week of Prayer for Christian Unity begins. Every year it constitutes, for believers in Christ, a propitious time to revive the ecumenical spirit, to meet each other, to get to know each other, to pray and reflect together. The biblical theme, taken from the Gospel of St. Luke, echoes the words of the risen Jesus to the apostles: “You are witnesses of these things” (Luke 24:48). Our proclamation of the Gospel of Jesus will be much more credible and effective the more that we are united in his love, as true brothers. Thus, I invite parishes, religious communities, ecclesial movements and associations to pray unceasingly, in a special way during Eucharistic Celebrations, for the complete unity of Christians.

Benedict XVI to the Jews of Rome


From the Vatican's unofficial translation of the Pope's address to the Jewish community in Rome yesterday:


2. The teaching of the Second Vatican Council has represented for Catholics a clear landmark to which constant reference is made in our attitude and our relations with the Jewish people, marking a new and significant stage. The Council gave a strong impetus to our irrevocable commitment to pursue the path of dialogue, fraternity and friendship, a journey which has been deepened and developed in the last forty years, through important steps and significant gestures. Among them, I should mention once again the historic visit by my Venerable Predecessor to this Synagogue on 13 April 1986, the numerous meetings he had with Jewish representatives, both here in Rome and during his Apostolic Visits throughout the world, the Jubilee Pilgrimage which he made to the Holy Land in the year 2000, the various documents of the Holy See which, following the Second Vatican Council’s Declaration Nostra Aetate, have made helpful contributions to the increasingly close relations between Catholics and Jews. I too, in the course of my Pontificate, have wanted to demonstrate my closeness to and my affection for the people of the Covenant. I cherish in my heart each moment of the pilgrimage that I had the joy of making to the Holy Land in May of last year, along with the memories of numerous meetings with Jewish Communities and Organizations, in particular my visits to the Synagogues of Cologne and New York.

Furthermore, the Church has not failed to deplore the failings of her sons and daughters, begging forgiveness for all that could in any way have contributed to the scourge of anti-Semitism and anti-Judaism (cf. Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews, We Remember: A Reflection on the Shoah, 16 March 1998). May these wounds be healed forever! The heartfelt prayer which Pope John Paul II offered at the Western Wall on 26 March 2000 comes back to my mind, and it calls forth a profound echo in our hearts: "God of our Fathers, you chose Abraham and his descendants to bring your Name to the nations: we are deeply saddened by the behaviour of those who in the course of history have caused these children of yours to suffer, and asking your forgiveness we wish to commit ourselves to genuine brotherhood with the people of the Covenant."

3. The passage of time allows us to recognize in the Twentieth Century a truly tragic period for humanity: ferocious wars that sowed destruction, death and suffering like never before; frightening ideologies, rooted in the idolatry of man, of race, and of the State, which led to brother killing brother. The singular and deeply disturbing drama of the Shoah represents, as it were, the most extreme point on the path of hatred that begins when man forgets his Creator and places himself at the centre of the universe. As I noted during my visit of 28 May 2006 to the Auschwitz Concentration camp, which is still profoundly impressed upon my memory, "the rulers of the Third Reich wanted to crush the entire Jewish people", and, essentially, "by wiping out this people, they intended to kill the God who called Abraham, who spoke on Sinai and laid down principles to serve as a guide for mankind, principles that remain eternally valid" (Discourse at Auschwitz-Birkenau Concentration Camp: The Teachings of Pope Benedict XVI, II, 1 [2006], p.727).

Here in this place, how could we not remember the Roman Jews who were snatched from their homes, before these very walls, and who with tremendous brutality were killed at Auschwitz? How could one ever forget their faces, their names, their tears, the desperation faced by these men, women and children? The extermination of the people of the Covenant of Moses, at first announced, then systematically programmed and put into practice in Europe under the Nazi regime, on that day tragically reached as far as Rome. Unfortunately, many remained indifferent, but many, including Italian Catholics, sustained by their faith and by Christian teaching, reacted with courage, often at risk of their lives, opening their arms to assist the Jewish fugitives who were being hunted down, and earning perennial gratitude. The Apostolic See itself provided assistance, often in a hidden and discreet way.

The memory of these events compels us to strengthen the bonds that unite us so that our mutual understanding, respect and acceptance may always increase.

4. Our closeness and spiritual fraternity find in the Holy Bible - in Hebrew Sifre Qodesh or "Book of Holiness" – their most stable and lasting foundation, which constantly reminds us of our common roots, our history and the rich spiritual patrimony that we share. It is in pondering her own mystery that the Church, the People of God of the New Covenant, discovers her own profound bond with the Jews, who were chosen by the Lord before all others to receive his word (cf. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 839). "The Jewish faith, unlike other non-Christian religions, is already a response to God’s revelation in the Old Covenant. To the Jews ‘belong the sonship, the glory, the covenants, the giving of the law, the worship, and the promises; to them belong the patriarchs and of their race, according to the flesh is the Christ’ (Rom 9:4-5), ‘for the gifts and the call of God are irrevocable!’ (Rom 11:29)" (Ibid).

5. Many lessons may be learnt from our common heritage derived from the Law and the Prophets. I would like to recall some of them: first of all, the solidarity which binds the Church to the Jewish people "at the level of their spiritual identity", which offers Christians the opportunity to promote "a renewed respect for the Jewish interpretation of the Old Testament" (cf. Pontifical Biblical Commission, The Jewish people and their Sacred Scriptures in the Christian Bible, 2001, pp.12 and 55); the centrality of the Decalogue as a common ethical message of permanent value for Israel, for the Church, for non-believers and for all of humanity; the task of preparing or ushering in the Kingdom of the Most High in the "care for creation" entrusted by God to man for him to cultivate and to care for responsibly (cf. Gen 2:15).

***

8. On this path we can walk together, aware of the differences that exist between us, but also aware of the fact that when we succeed in uniting our hearts and our hands in response to the Lord’s call, his light comes closer and shines on all the peoples of the world. The progress made in the last forty years by the International Committee for Catholic-Jewish Relations and, in more recent years, by the Mixed Commission of the Chief Rabbinate of Israel and of the Holy See, are a sign of our common will to continue an open and sincere dialogue. Tomorrow here in Rome, in fact, the Mixed Commission will hold its ninth meeting, on "Catholic and Jewish Teaching on Creation and the Environment"; we wish them a profitable dialogue on such a timely and important theme.


The picture is from Daylife.

Announcements

1) On January 16, 2010, at 11:00 A.M., Dario Cardinal Castrillon Hoyos will offer Solemn Pontifical Mass at the Chiesa dell'Ascensione a Chiaja in Naples. (Source)

2) On January 24, 2010, at 11:00 A.M., Archbishop Raymond Burke will offer Solemn Pontifical Mass from the throne at the Chiesa Parrocchiale di San Sebastiano ad Artallo in Imperia. He will then preside over Pontifical Vespers in the same parish church at 3:30 P.M. (Source)

UPDATE: The Mass of Cardinal Castrillon Hoyos was canceled almost at the last minute.

Still looking for an Ordo?




For more details: New Liturgical Ordo for 2010

THE POPE
on the SSPX
and Anglicans

VATICAN CITY, 15 JAN 2010 (VIS) - Participants in the annual plenary assembly of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the president of which is Cardinal William Joseph Levada, were received this morning by the Holy Father. In his address to them he highlighted the fact that their dicastery "participates in the ministry of unity" which is primarily entrusted to the Pope through his "commitment to doctrinal fidelity.

"Unity", he added, "is first and foremost unity of faith, upheld by the sacred tradition of which Peter's Successor is the primary custodian and defender. ... This is an indispensable service upon which depends the effectiveness of the Church's evangelising activity unto the end of time.

"The Bishop of Rome", the Pope explained, "must constantly proclaim that ... Jesus is Lord". The Roman Pontiff's "potestas docendi" requires "obedience to the faith, so that the Truth that is Christ may continue to shine forth in all its grandeur, ... and that there may be a single flock gathered around a single Shepherd".

The goal of a shared witness of faith among all Christians "represents, then, a priority for the Church in all periods of history. ... In this spirit, I trust particularly in your dicastery's commitment to overcoming the doctrinal problems that still persist in achieving the full communion of the Society of St. Pius X with the Church".

Benedict XVI then went on to thank the members of the congregation for their efforts towards "the full integration of groups and individuals of former Anglican faithful into the life of the Catholic Church, in accordance with the provisions of the Apostolic Constitution 'Anglicanorum coetibus'. The faithful adherence of these groups to the truth received from Christ and presented in the Magisterium of the Church is in no way contrary to the ecumenical movement", he said, "rather, it reveals the ultimate aim thereof, which is the realisation of the full and visible communion of the disciples of the Lord".

The Pope then turned his attention to the Instruction "Dignitas Personae" concerning certain bioethical questions, which was published by the congregation in 2008. "It represents", he said, "a new milestone in the announcement of the Gospel, in full continuity with the Instruction 'Donum vitae' published by the dicastery in 1987. In such delicate and pressing questions as those that concern procreation and the new therapeutic advances involving the manipulation of the embryo and the human genetic patrimony, ... the Magisterium of the Church seeks to offer its own contribution to the formation of consciences, not only the consciences of believers but of everyone who seeks the truth and is willing to listen to arguments that arise not only from the faith, but also from reason itself".

"Christian faith also makes its truthful contribution in the field of ethics and philosophy, not supplying prefabricated solutions to real problems such as biomedical research and experimentation, put presenting moral standpoints within which human reason can seek and find appropriate solutions", said the Pope.

And he went on: "There are, in fact, certain aspects of Christian revelation that throw light on the problems of bioethics. ... These aspects, inscribed in the heart of man, are also understandable in rational terms as elements of natural moral law, and may find acceptance even among people who do not recognise themselves in the Christian faith".

"Rooted in human nature and accessible to all creatures possessing reason, natural moral law constitutes the foundation for opening a dialogue with all men and women who seek the truth and, more generally, with civil and secular society", said Pope Benedict. And he concluded: "This law, inscribed in the heart of all human beings, touches an essential aspect of legal theory and appeals to legislators' consciences and sense of responsibility".
---

The True Reform of Pope Ratzinger

The New Theological Movement has published a partial translation of the interview given by Antonio Cardinal Canizares-Llovera to Il Foglio, and published on January 9, 2010.

The emphases are from RC.


January 9, 2010, Il Foglio


The ex-archbishop of Toledo and primate of Spain, Cardinal Antonio Cañizares has led the Vatican "ministry" which occupies itself with the liturgy for a little than a year. A delicate task in a pontificate, such as that of Benedict XVI, in which the liturgy and its "restructuring" has a central role after the post conciliar diversions. The liturgy is the center, after all, of the life of the faithful. The Pope said it again at the Christmas Vigil: as for the monks, so it is for every man, "the liturgy is the first priority. Everything else comes after." It is necessary, "to put in second place all other occupations, as important as they may be, to set out toward God, to allow Him to enter into our life and our time."

Cardinal Cañizares says as much to Il Foglio and more in an assessment after having passed one year in the Roman Curia:

"I have received - he explains - the mission to complete, with the indispensable and most valid help of my collaborators, those tasks which have been assigned to the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments in the Apostolic Constitution Pastor Bonus of John Paul II with respect to the order and promotion of the sacred liturgy, in the first place of the sacraments. For the religious and cultural situation in which we live and for the same priority which corresponds to the liturgy in the life of the Church, I believe that the principal mission which I have received is to promote with complete dedication and engagement, to reinvigorate and develop the spirit and the true sense of the liturgy in the conscience and life of the faithful; so that the liturgy becomes the center and the heart of the community; so that all, priests and faithful, consider it as the substantial and essential thing of our life; so that we live the liturgy in full truth; so that in all its fullness, as the Second Vatican Council says, it is "the source and summit" of the Christian life. After a year at the helm of this Congregation, I experience and sense with greater force every day, the necessity of promoting in the Church, in every continent, a strong and rigorous liturgical impulse. An impulse which revivifies that most rich heritage of the Council and of which the great liturgical movement of the 19th and first half of the 20th century - with men like Guardini, Jungmann and so many others - rendered fruitful the Church at the Second Vatican Council. There, without any doubt, stands our future and the future of the world. I say this because the future of the Church and of the entirety of humanity is answered in God, in the life of God and of that which comes from Him; and this happens in the liturgy and by means of it. Only a Church which lives the truth of the liturgy will be in a position to give the one thing which can renew, transform and recreate the world: God and only God and His grace. The liturgy, in its most pure character, is the presence of God, the salvific and regenerating work of God, communication and participation in His merciful love, adoration, acknowledgement of God. It is the only thing that can save us."

Guardini and Jungmann were two pillars of the liturgical renewal of the past decades. Figures which also inspired Joseph Ratzinger in his The Spirit of the Liturgy. Figures which, probably, have also inspired the promulgation of the Motu Proprio, Summorum Pontificum. It is said that the Motu Proprio has represented also (there are some who say it at least) an extended hand of the Pope to the Society of Saint Pius X. Is this so?

"In fact, it is. However, I believe that the Motu Proprio has a most important value for its own sake, for the Church and for the liturgy. Although this displeases some - judging by the reactions which have arrived and which continue to arrive - it is only just and necessary to say that the Motu Proprio is not a step back or a return to the past. It is to acknowledge and receive, with simplicity, in all its fullness, the treasures and inheritance of the great Tradition, which has in the liturgy its most genuine and profound expression. The Church cannot permit herself to prescind, to forget or to renounce the treasures and the rich inheritance of this tradition, contained in the Roman Rite. It would be a betrayal and a negation of her very self. She cannot abandon the historical inheritance of the ecclesiastical liturgy, or desire to establish everything from anew - as some have pretended - without cutting off fundamental parts of the Church herself. Some understood the Conciliar liturgical reform as a rupture, and not as an organic development of the tradition. In these years after the Council, "change" was almost a magic word; it became necessary to modify that which had been, to the point of forgetting it; everything new; it was necessary to introduce novelty, in the end, a human work and creation. We cannot forget that the liturgical reform and the years after the Council coincided with a cultural climate intensely marked and dominated by a conception of man as 'creator' that only with difficulty co-exists with a liturgy, which, above all, is the action of God and His priority, "the right" of God, adoration of God and also the tradition of that which we receive and has been given to us one time and for all times. We are not able to create the liturgy ourselves, it is not our work, but the work of God. This conception of man as 'creator' which leads to a secularized vision of everything, where God, often, has no place, this passion for change and the loss of tradition has not yet been overcome. And for this reason, in my opinion, among the other things, stands the cause by which many see with such distrust the Motu Proprio or that it displeases some so much to receive and accept it, to re-encounter the great riches of the Roman liturgical tradition which we cannot squander, or to search for and accept the reciprocal enrichment of the one Roman rite between the "ordinary" and the "extraordinary" forms. The Motu Proprio, Summorum Pontificum, has a most important value, which everyone ought to appreciate, whose value has not only to do with the liturgy, but the entire Church, of that which it is and the tradition it signifies, without which the Church turns into a human institution always in change. Obviously, the Motu Proprio has to be seen with the reading and interpretation one makes or would make of the Second Vatican Council. When one reads the Council and interprets it with the key of rupture and discontinuity, he understands nothing of the Council and he completely distorts it. For this reason, as the Pope indicates, only a hermeneutic of continuity brings us to a just and correct reading of the Council, and to understand the truth of that which it says and teaches in its entirety and in particular in the Constitution, Sacrosanctum Concilium, on the divine liturgy, which is inseparable, for the most part, with this same entirety. Consequently, the Motu Proprio also has a most high value for the communion of the Church."

The Pope stands behind the slow but necessary process of the Church's rapprochement to an authentic liturgical spirit. Also, divisions and contra-positions are not lacking. Cardinal Cañizares speaks about it:

"The great contribution of the Pope, in my opinion, is that he is bringing us closer to the truth of the liturgy, with a wise pedagogy, introducing us to the genuine 'spirit' of the liturgy (the title of one of his works before becoming Pope). He, before all else, is following a simple educative process which seeks to move toward this 'spirit' or genuine sense of the liturgy, to overcome a reductive vision which is still very entrenched. As Pope, he is the first to put into practice his teachings, so rich and abundant in this area. As his evocative gestures which accompany the celebrations at which he presides, move in this direction. To accept these gestures and these teachings is a duty which we have if we are disposed to live the liturgy in a way corresponding to its very naturalness and if we do not want to lose the treasures and liturgical inheritance of the tradition. Further, they constitute a great gift for the formation, as urgent as it is necessary, of the Christian people. In this prospective, one needs to see the same Motu Proprio which has confirmed the possibility to celebrate with the Roman Missal approved by John XXIII and which goes back, with the successive modifications, to the time of Saint Gregory the Great and even earlier. It is certain that there are many difficulties which those are having who, in utilizing that which is their right, are celebrating or participating in the Holy Mass according to "the ancient rite" or "extraordinary" form. Of itself, there need not be this opposition, or even less to be seen as suspect or labeled as "pre-conciliar" or, even worse, as "anti-conciliar." The reasons for this are many and diverse. However, at bottom, they are the same which they carry to the reform of the liturgy understood as rupture and not in the horizon of the tradition and the 'hermeneutic of continuity' which reclaims the renewal and true liturgical reform in the key of Vatican II. We cannot forget, further, that in the liturgy one touches that which is most essential to the faith and the Church and, for this reason, every time in history when one has touched something of liturgical tensions, divisions have not been rare."

(The picture is from the ICRSS website)

The New Liturgical Movement has also published a fuller (but, apparently, not yet complete) translation of the same interview.

Pray for Haiti


The picture is from Daylife.

The Archbishop of Port-au-Prince, Msgr. Joseph Serge Miot, is among the dead.

Attack on Creation

[W]e must remember that the problem of the environment is complex; one might compare it to a multifaceted prism. Creatures differ from one another and can be protected, or endangered, in different ways, as we know from daily experience.

One such attack comes from laws or proposals which, in the name of fighting discrimination, strike at the biological basis of the difference between the sexes. I am thinking, for example, of certain countries in Europe or North and South America.

Saint Columban stated that: "If you take away freedom, you take away dignity" (Ep. 4 ad Attela, in S. Columbani Opera, Dublin, 1957, p. 34). Yet freedom cannot be absolute, since man is not himself God, but the image of God, God’s creation. For man, the path to be taken cannot be determined by caprice or willfulness, but must rather correspond to the structure willed by the Creator.
Benedict XVI
January 11, 2010

The Collapse of the Church in France

The IFOP Institute has just made a survey on Catholicism in France for the daily La Croix. The result is mind-blowing:

  • Whilst, in 1965, 81% of the French declared themselves as Catholics, they were no more than 64% in 2009.
  • More serious: whilst 27% of the French went to Mass once a week or more in 1965, they are no more than 4.5% in 2009.
  • At a doctrinal level, generally, it’s a catastrophe: 63% of practicing Catholics think all religions are the same; 75% ask for an “aggiornamento” of the Church on contraception and even 68% for abortion.
  • As for communion with the Roman Pontiff, the situation is no better: only 27% of practicing Catholics consider that Benedict XVI “rather well” defends “the values of Catholicism” (personally, I don’t even understand the question, but that doesn’t matter) when 34% think he defends them “rather badly”.

That’s the least we could say, that in view of the figures, it is urgent to change the strategy and reunite the living forces of French Catholicism to re-evangelise the former Eldest Daughter of the Church! To find all the survey data (in French): “La Croix“.


Read more in The Anglo-Catholic


Pontifical Mass Pictures from Copenhagen

Pictures of the Solemn Pontifical Mass offered this previous Sunday by Bishop Czeslaw Kozon are now on Katolsk Tradition. The Bishop was assisted by Fr. Josef Bisig and Fr. Martin Knudsen, both of the Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter.

Paix Liturgique on the Reform of the Reform

Paix Liturgique has published its second English letter, which contains the following essay:

Second Aim of the Motu Proprio: The Reform of the Reform



The increasing availability of Msgr Nicola Bux’s book The Reform of Benedict XVI [1] is an opportunity for us to depart somewhat from our usual focus on the application of the motu proprio “Summorum Pontificum” and to take stock of the “reform of the reform” that the Holy Pontiff has initiated in liturgy. It is also the occasion to consider what sort of relationship will slowly emerge between the two forms of the Roman liturgy.

The first aim of the motu proprio “Summorum Pontificum” is clear: to make it possible for the traditional Mass to be celebrated in every parish where it is requested. The MP will only truly be applied when we shall see the ten o’clock Sunday Mass celebrated in the ordinary form and the eleven o’clock Mass in the extraordinary form, or the reverse, in the cathedrals of Dublin or Detroit, as well as in the cathedrals of Boise or Aberdeen. In a word: as far as the MP’s application is concerned, we are still on the starting line.

Read more here.

Recent Pontifical Masses by cardinals: some pictures and a short comment



As previously announced on Rorate, Cardinal Castrillon Hoyos offered Solemn Pontifical Mass in Osimo on January 6, while Cardinal Canizares Llovera did so in St. John Lateran yesterday, January 7. The New Liturgical Movement and Orbis Catholicus have magnificent pictures of the Mass of Cardinal Canizares Llovera, while Rinascimento Sacro has the pictures of Cardinal Castrillon Hoyos pontificating in the Campocavallo sanctuary.

(Joseph Cardinal Zen, emeritus of Hong Kong, also celebrated a Missa Cantata in Hong Kong last December 27.)

The sight of these sumptuous Masses and other services being celebrated by Cardinals of the Holy Roman Catholic Church should be a matter of great rejoicing for all who love the Catholic faith, and are signs of hope for the future of the Church. There can be no gainsaying that here, we see great progress. In particular, the offering of Pontifical Masses in the two greatest basilicas of Christendom cannot but signal how much has changed since the days of the three previous Pontificates.

At the same time, it should be noted that out of 183 cardinals (as of the time of this writing), only six Cardinals publicly celebrate the Mass of the Missal of 1962 with some regularity (meaning, at least once a year or more): Cardinal Castrillon Hoyos (retired), Cardinal Rode (still active, but past retirement age), Cardinal Canizares-Llovera, Cardinal Pell of Sydney, Cardinal Zen the emeritus of Hong Kong, and Cardinal Medina Estevez (retired, former Prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship). Of these six cardinals, only Cardinal Rode had not already offered it (as a bishop) prior to September 14, 2007. Some cardinals still living offered this Mass prior to 2007, but are now, perhaps, too old to offer it in public.

Since 2007, Cardinal Ricard of Bordeaux and Cardinal Vingt-Trois of Paris have also offered the occasional Mass. Solemn Masses have been offered as well in the presence of Cardinal Barbarin of Lyons and Cardinal George of Chicago.

We pray and hope that more Cardinals -- especially those actually reigning as Archbishops, and still quite young -- will offer the Traditional Latin Mass as well, and soon.

Protect the Pope, return the sedia!


The use of the sedia continued until very recently and many are unaware that the last pope to use the sedia was actually Pope John Paul I. While the abolition of this ancient form of transport may have since been considered appropriate in the context of the late 20th century and the need to democratise the appearance of papal ceremonies, the reality has left the Pope an isolated and vulnerable figure separated from the deacons ahead and the MCs behind, one who appears all too often like the figure in the Third Secret of Fatima: a victim walking alone simply waiting to be attacked.

While there are bound to be some who would see the return of the sedia as yet another example of this Pope "turning the clock back", in fact not only would it save an elderly man's tired legs but it would allow more of the crowd to see him. Most importantly, it would actually insulate him from the kind of physical assault we saw at Christmas by virtue of the mob of people surrounding it (who could these days be swelled by Swiss Guards and the gendarme officers in suitably formal garb) to work alongside the suited officers at the perimeter.


Naturally, the risk of attack from a gunman or explosive device would still be present and indeed potentially magnified by the sedia but the use of X-ray machines at the entrance to the basilica and physical searches of congregants should by now be mandatory at such events to confront these risks which are no more heightened by the Pope presiding at Mass from an elevated platform, as he does, than from being carried in a chair.


It was being reported earlier in the year on several Catholic blogs that the Vatican was actively considering a return for the sedia gestatoria for ceremonies in St Peter's, more because of the Pope's age than as a protection against attack. Perhaps the latest incident will persuade them that what tradition hands down frequently has a practical origin beyond merely the visually impressive spectacle that to sceptical modern eyes it had appeared to have become.

From the Catholic Herald, January 8, 2010.

Source for the pic: link.

Julian Christmas Greetings!


To all the Greek Catholics and other Eastern Christians who, on this day, observe the Feast of the Nativity of the Lord: A Blessed and Joyful Christmas!

Msgr. Graham Leonard 1921-2010

I have total confidence always in the loving power of God and in His objectives for humanity. I trust God totally and, because I believe in God, I believe in the Church that He has given us and that is why I have hope. It is this Church that must carry to fulfillment the plan of God for the salvation of man. (Source)


(H/t for the news to The Anglo-Catholic. More can be found here, here and here.)