Rorate Caeli

Keep on doing what you are doing, Cardinal Vallini! It's working!

When a group of priests whine publicly that their superior is being "authoritarian", we must admit that our immediate reaction is to defend the superior; and when the "climate of fear" decried by these priests is a "climate" of "internal police" related to, shall we say, "homosexual matters" - well, then we are absolutely certain that the superior is correct and that whatever he is doing is certainly in the right direction.

Here is our support to Cardinal Vicar-General Vallini: we do not know what you are doing, Your Eminence, but you are doing it right.

[Source: Il Messaggero; Tip: Papa Ratzinger blog]

Letter of Roman priests against [Cardinal Vicar-General] Vallini - "Impressive authoritarianism"

by Franca Giansoldati

ROME - The gossip-letter writer has acted once again - but this time, the letter that arrived four days ago for all heads of offices across the Tiber [in the Roman Curia] is not anonymous, but signed by "The priests of Rome". Even Pope Ratzinger has received it on his desk, himself being the first addressee ("Your Holiness, this is an open letter, and not one of those that go around in the Curia in these weeks.")
The letter is composed of two computer-written pages, in eight paragraphs from which transpire suffering, delusion, and, in certain parts, exasperation for a sad climate of "impressive authoritarianism".

The cardinal - former prefect of the Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura, chosen by the Pontiff to replace Camillo Ruini in 2008 - is accused of displaying "attitudes worthy of an officer of the carabinieri, not of a bishop". The discontent moves through the diocesan clergy and perhaps, considering the initiative, [it does] not [date] from yesterday. In the curia, this is all that is being discussed. The authors of the letter regret being unable to have serene conversations with their own superior due to a "climate of suspicion regarding everything and everyone" which has been created with time. In sum: the Lateran palace [seat of the Diocesan administration] is depicted as a place not of dialogue, but as an "unhappy place where no one is trusted and one is bound to silence."
[From the letter:] "Another painful chapter is the relationship with us, priests. We hoped - it is written - to have a day of the week at our disposal to be received without appointment. We now even fear approaching that office. We are looked upon with suspicion, judged and criticized without being able to defend ourselves and blackmailed with the possibility of being left without stipend."

But why has so much hostility been piling up against the Cardinal-Vicar, a man trusted by Pope Ratzinger, from the Roman priests, to the point of writing an open letter to the Bishop of Rome? Vallini has been blamed for an excessive firmness in moving forward with an action of internal police in order to expel from the diocese the rotten apples, gay priests [sic]. The toughness with which he has moved with no regard for anyone would have aggravated many minds? Priests would have been deposed suddently and without many explanations, without real reaons. [From the letter:] "He [Vallini] is obsessed about the suspicion of homosexuality, as if rare cases which happened in the diocese should compromise the integrity of the entire presbyterate."

"Rare cases"?... There have been magazine reports and books dedicated to just a few of them! Auguri, Eminenza! Il mondo cattolico è con voi!


  1. Joaquín7:30 PM


    Exactly what I thought when i read about this...

  2. Kathleen8:11 PM

    [Cardinal] Vallini has been clamed for an excessive firmness in moving forward with an action of internal police in order to expel from the diocese the rotten apples, gay priests

    May God richly bless him!

    Keeping Cardinal Vallini in our regular prayers would seem appropriate, since the sodomites will undoubtedly be doing their best to make him suffer for daring to cleanse Holy Mother Church of them.

  3. I don't get it why is the good Cardinal a bad guy again?

  4. Because he is "insensitive", perhaps?... Like a "maresciallo dei carabinieri" or something...

  5. Anonymous11:04 PM

    You start kicking away the sodomite priests, and hordes of sodomite priests write to you saying that you are obsessed with them, they aren't very many....

    Spot the error...

    By the way, that with the Carabinieri officer was a beautiful compliment.


  6. Giovanni A. Cattaneo said...

    "I don't get it why is the good Cardinal a bad guy again?"

    Because we are living in a time when (I think it was Chesterton who said this) "What is white is considered black and what is black is considered not so dark."

  7. Gratias3:52 AM

    Gays in the Church are the stalking horse for Marxism (you know, dialectical materialism). Chase them out, Cardinal Vallini.

  8. J.G. Ratkay11:53 AM

    May His Eminence Cardinal Vallini continiue to be a mayor player in the purification of the roman diocese.

  9. ncstevem2:03 PM


    It's not 'gays', it's sodomites.

    We need to take the language back in order to win the battle.

  10. SCIJ_Roma3:33 PM

    Mi sembra che la ricerca della verità non sia il vostro forte. Vi consiglio di leggere la lettera in originale anzichè eccitarvi con le parole "autoritarismo ed omofobia" riportate da un articolo di un quotidiano

    Il sacerdote arrivato alla morte in agosto era un vostro fratello...non penso che meritasse tanta crudeltà

  11. What we can say, dear friend (Father?), is that all toughness is necessary - an it may be indeed too late for the good name of what should be the most spotless diocese in the world. If Vallini finds his main support among the "Kikos", what can be done? Perhaps the traditional-minded priests should support him publicly, and not undermine his efforts. Otherwise, he will find those who are willing to support him, even if they are Bugninians or "Neocats".

    What do you think outsiders grasp from a letter, even if written with the best of intentions, in which the Cardinal-Vicar is accused of "autoritarismo" (authoritarianism) and "ossessione per il sesso" (obsession with sex)? They grasp that the Cardinal-Vicar is bothering the right people - and it is very unfortunate if others are hurt in the process; if the latter are innocent, they should stand their ground and bear their cross.


  12. Gratias4:36 AM

    Nostro forte e la restaurazione della fede catolica.


Comment boxes are debate forums for readers and contributors of RORATE CÆLI.

Please, DO NOT assume that RORATE CÆLI contributors or moderators necessarily agree with or otherwise endorse any particular comment just because they let it stand.


(1) This is our living room, in a deeply Catholic house, and you are our guest. Please, behave accordingly. Any comment may be blocked or deleted, at any time, whenever we perceive anything that is not up to our standards, not conducive to a healthy conversation or a healthy Catholic environment, or simply not to our liking.

(2) By clicking on the "publish your comment" button, please remain aware that you are choosing to make your comment public - that is, the comment box is not to be used for private and confidential correspondence with contributors and moderators.

(3) Any name/ pseudonym/ denomination may be freely used simply by choosing the third option, "Name/URL" (the URL box may be left empty), when posting your comment - therefore, there is no reason whatsoever to simply post as "Anonymous", making debate unnecessarily harder to follow. Any comment signed simply as "Anonymous" will be blocked.

Thank you!