Silence in the Liturgy
Silence in the Liturgy
Procession:
Algunas fotos de la procesión de la peregrinación Populus Summorum Pontificum 2021 hacia San Pedro en el Vaticano. #sumpont2021 pic.twitter.com/ca2WgEZpdh
— Una Voce España (@unavocespana) October 30, 2021
Images of the 10th Summorum Pontificum Rome pilgrimage today #sumpont2021 pic.twitter.com/jZoMLQYveb
— Edward Pentin (@EdwardPentin) October 30, 2021
In this installment, divided into two parts because of its rich and lengthy content, Don Pietro analyzes the Council’s underhanded suppression of the Kingship of Christ and the Feast of Christ the King, established by Pope Pius XI in 1925 and promulgated in his memorable and most beautiful encyclical Quas Primas. First, Don Pietro examines the silence of the Council’s documents on this Feast and second, its obfuscation through the changes made in the Mass and the Liturgy of the Hours as regards scripture readings, prayers and hymns and in the process, cancelling the many references to Our Lord’s Kingship. This was all accomplished through duplicity and dishonesty and has led to the uncrowning of Christ the King and His Social Kingship. To quote Pope Pius XI 'At the last judgment, Christ will accuse those who have expelled Him from public life and will have the most terrible vengeance from such an outrage.' Part (b) to this installment will be posted tomorrow. F.R.
Celebrate it, and they will come.Multitude fills the Pantheon in Rome Friday night for Traditional Vespers.#sumpont2021 pic.twitter.com/nMt8spDRLZ— Rorate Caeli (@RorateCaeli) October 29, 2021
***
by Nicole Winfield [Excerpts]
[Rome, October 30, 2021:] Traditionalist Catholics descended on Rome on Friday for their annual pilgrimage, hoping to show the vibrancy of their community after Pope Francis issued a crackdown on the spread of the old Latin Mass that many took as an attack on them and the ancient rite.
An evening vespers service at Rome’s Pantheon basilica, the first event of the three-day pilgrimage, was so full that ushers had to add two rows of chairs to accommodate the faithful. Many young families, couples and priests filled the pews, hailing from the U.S., France, Spain and beyond.
VERY IMPORTANT NEWS AND REVELATIONS ON TRADITIONIS
CUSTODES IN POLAND.
From the Messainlatino Blogspot
Cardinal
Nycz comments on Traditionis Custodes: it was acknowledged in the
Congregation that the issue was dealt with too harshly.
Cardinal
Kazimierz Nycz’s statement on the
discussions held recently on “Traditionis Custodes” at the Congregation for Divine Worship and the
Discipline of the Sacraments. The Metropolitan
of Warsaw said that “It was acknowledged in Congregation that the
question had been dealt with too harshly and instead of serving unity, in
individual cases, it may well make some leave the Church.”
Upon
his return to Poland after the ad limina
visit to the Vatican, Cardinal Nycz shared his observations about his Vatican sojourn
in a interview with KAI (Polish Catholic
News Agency). He also answered questions with regard to the procedure of
the meetings, as well as to questions raised during many conversations with the
functionaries of the Roman Curia and individual Congregations. The Primate
admitted that during his visit, the Polish bishops also discussed Pope Francis’
Motu Proprio “Traditionis Custodes” , which radically limited the possibility of
celebrating Holy Mass in the Extraordinary Form.
“There
was a very interesting discussion in the Liturgical Congregation concerning the
Tridentine Liturgy. The bishops asked questions, mainly in relation to parish churches, where this liturgy could still be celebrated,
in conformity with the Motu Proprio “Traditionis
Custodes” if there was such a need in Poland in the future.”
If you have been a long-time reader of Rorate you know we love and support the wonderful Benedictines of Mary, Queen of Apostles. Their numerous CDs have topped the classical music charts for years, enabling them to spread the Word of God through music, and continue their mission through the proceeds.
Now, after a three-year hiatus, they have released their 10th CD -- this one in honor of Christ the King.
All proceeds will go toward the construction of a permanent monastery for the Abbey’s growing daughter house in the Ozark mountains of southern Missouri.
For only $15 this CD will make a great stocking stuffer for Christmas or a gift for St. Nicholas's feast day. You can purchase five or more at a discounted rate.
TO PURCHASE THE CD, CLICK HERE
TO SEE PLANS FOR THE DAUGHTER HOUSE, CLICK HERE
Conference at Hotel Massimo d’Azeglio, Rome
– 23 October 2021
I have divided this talk into two sections: I will first reflect on the importance of nourishing the spiritual life in a situation of calamity, that is, when it is more difficult to decipher the presence of God and therefore a more solid faith and hope are required, and then I will try to offer an interpretation of the present epidemic-pandemic situation caused by COVID-19, highlighting the causes of the markedly inadequate theological-spiritual response to the phenomenon.
Miniature of Saint Luke from the Grandes Heures of Anne of Brittany (1503–1508) by Jean Bourdichon |
From the Epistle: For our wrestling is not against flesh and blood, but against the Principalities and the Powers, against the world-rulers of this darkness, against the spiritual forces of wickedness on high. (Ephesians 6:12)
In this installment, Don Pietro focuses further on the origins of the concept of ‘Religious Liberty’ which has wormed its way into the Church and minds and hearts of countless Catholics, contradicting centuries of Church teaching. We shall see in more detail how this notion of religious liberty reflects the concepts of the American Constitution and the French Revolution’s ‘Declaration on the Rights of Man’, emanating from the Freemasonic ideals and philosophy of the likes of Jean-Jacque Rousseau, an opposer of the order of natural morality, and one who believed in the concept of ‘The Sovereign People’ and their right to ‘self-determination.’ Don Pietro emphasizes that the Council’s obsession about religious liberty contradicts centuries of papal documents in which they denounce it as: ‘insanity’; ‘a monstrous error’; ‘most pernicious to the Catholic Church and the salvation of souls’; ‘the liberty of perdition’ ; ‘the pest of indifference’ ; ‘a public crime’ ; and ‘atheism, however it may differ in name’ (See the sources for these quotes in the footnotes of this installment).
F.R.
THE COUNCIL AND THE ECLIPSE OF GOD
Paul VI claims as a basis for the new Lectionary for Mass, the 1989 Ordo Lectionum Missae, the prescription of the Second Vatican Council in Sacrosanctum Concilium that “over the course of a prescribed number of years a more representative portion of Holy Scripture be read to the people”. As to the new ordering of the Lectionary, the Pope continues: “All these things have been arranged in this way so as to arouse more and more among Christ’s faithful that hunger for the Word of God by which under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, the people of the New Covenant can be seen, as it were, to be impelled towards the perfect unity of the Church.”
Reactions to Traditionis Custodes
Ecce nova facio omnia.
Behold, I make all things new.
(Ap 21:5)
Dear Brothers and Sisters,
My dearly beloved Sons,
The feast of the Dedication in the liturgical year belongs neither to the temporal cycle, which goes through the mysteries in Christ’s life, the times of Advent, Christmas, Epiphany, Lent, Easter and Pentecost, nor to the Sanctoral cycle, in which the Church invites her children, through a public worship, to imitate the life of those who have lived their lives listening to grace, and according to God’s law, and whom she has proclaimed saints.
Monastery of Sant Jeroni de la Murtra, near Barcelona, where the Catholic Monarchs welcomed Columbus back from the Indies in 1493 |
Now that four centuries have sped since a Ligurian first, under God's guidance, touched shores unknown beyond the Atlantic, the whole world is eager to celebrate the memory of the event, and glorify its author. Nor could a worthier reason be found where through zeal should be kindled. For the exploit is in itself the highest and grandest which any age has ever seen accomplished by man; and he who achieved it, for the greatness of his mind and heart, can be compared to but few in the history of humanity.
"Let’s examine what has now come to light about each of these three questions."
Thank you, Diane Montagna, for your tireless work in uncovering the truth, unsavory as it too often is, of what is really going on in the Vatican. (Read the whole exposé here.)
Now a word to Diane and any Vaticanistas who have access to the CDF internal report: please, for the love of God and the love of Holy Mother Church, find a way to publish this report IN FULL, so that all the world can see the lies exposed, and with them, the mettle of the people who are assaulting the tradition of the Roman Church. Its full publication would be as great a moment of clarity as Archbishop Viganò's McCarrick revelations in August 2018. This is an urgent duty of conscience: the pontifical secret cannot be invoked for hiding malice and mendacity.
Traditional High Mass of Requiem in Corpus Christi, Maiden Lane, in London |
Reproduced with permission from the Voice of the Family Digest. To subscribe to this weekly newsletter, scroll to the bottom of this page and enter your email address.
----------------------------
In 1570 Pope St Pius V promulgated a new edition of the Missale Romanum, the Roman Missal, as mandated by the Council of Trent (1545-1563). The event was an important one, but it has often been misunderstood. At a moment of liturgical crisis, it would be good to remind ourselves of its real significance.Some bishops just talk. Some demonstrate pure evil or hatred. Some -- even typically good ones -- panic when the going gets tough. But the best ones lead by example.
Dear Brothers and Sisters,
My dearly beloved Sons,
The richness of the feast of the Holy Rosary, which unfolds both in the texts of the Mass and in those of the office, leads us to ponder all the mysteries of the Lord’s life through Mary’s eyes and heart. Pius XII wrote on August 7th, 1947, to the members of a congress which took place in Paris, and then in Lisieux between September 23rd and 30th, on the occasion of the fiftieth anniversary of St. Thérèse of the Child Jesus:
Whereas in the order of nature a child, as he grows, should learn to become self-sufficient, in the order of grace, the child of God, as he grows, understands ever better that he will never be able to be self-sufficient, and that he should live in a superior docility and dependence.
Who might forget that if Mary gave birth without pain to Jesus in the Bethlehem stable, the all-sorrowful Virgin received all of us as her children and gave birth to us at the foot of the Cross: “Woman, behold thy son… behold thy mother.” (Jn 19:26-27) John the Evangelist, to whom these words were addressed, adds consequently: “And from that hour, the disciple took her to his own.”
We cannot but recall that four great Roman Pontiffs came from the Dominican ranks. Of these, the last, St. Pius V, won undying gratitude from Christianity and civil society. He joined together, after unceasing efforts, the arms of the Catholic princes, and under the patronage of the Virgin Mother of God, whom, therefore, he ordered to be saluted in future as Help to Christians, destroyed forever at Lepanto the power of the Turks.
Each age has its own distortion of God, what people imagine Him to be. This present age, at least in these United States among Catholics, is tempted to romanticize God, make Him warm and fuzzy, and in that way really neutralize His presence in one’s personal life. It is almost a Catholic way of secularizing God. God has become the product of the community, a predictable pet—yes, still a powerful pet, someone beyond the sunset, but still in His box, and that box we keep Him in is called "the community". Those many passages in the Old Testament that speak of the wildness of God, of the unpredictability of God, of the God who is a jealous God, the God who is the judge of all, the God who displays wrath: any of these attributes of God that we find unpleasant or threatening to our religious complacency and happiness are denied, and we say: Oh, that is not MY God!” Or, “We have out-grown that picture of God. All that stuff is the God of the Old Testament. The New Testament God is very different, much more likable, more lovable. Jesus’ God is quite different: a God of mercy, of compassion, of love.”
Dispelling the Myths of the Post-Vatican II Liturgical Reforms
Over the last decade in particular, the figure of 17% has been quoted as the proportion of prayers that survived intact from the traditional Roman Missal into the novus ordo of Paul VI. [1] However, in the wake of Traditionis custodes, with renewed attention being given to the comparison of ‘forms’ of the Roman Rite as well as the canonical and theological controversy over what counts as its lex orandi, [2] it seemed opportune to build on some of my previous efforts and revisit this percentage through a careful and exhaustive analysis of all the orations. By doing this, not only can we arrive at a definitive number, but we can also now have all the relevant data freely and easily accessible in the public domain, so that everyone can see which prayers were preserved, edited or discarded. [3]
From the Alleluia for the Feast of Saint Michael the Archangel:
Holy Archangel Michael, defend us in battle: that we may not perish in the dreadful judgment. Alleluia.
Michaelmass; just the sound of the word evokes images, thoughts, echoes. The first time I ever heard the term was when I arrived in Oxford as a student now many years ago and was told that in a few days the Michaelmas Term would begin. I was charmed and delighted to think that a university would name its terms in specifically Christian terms: Michaelmas, Hilary and Trinity, the three terms of the academic year. But this was part of the paradox of a place like Oxford where the cloud of secularism has penetrated the very stones of which the colleges are built and still the term Michaelmas is used, a term that evokes a time, a time when Catholic culture and faith infused the life of a university. And there are Michaelmas daisies, something like our mums, flowers that herald the time of autumn, of falling leaves, but also of the fall towards winter, the time of quiet and cold, of remembering, of hoping, the time when the light fades fast, but also the time when the celebration of the true Light that came into the world is taken up with such fervor in a world that denies the Light. One could go on further about what Michaelmas meant in the time of Catholic culture. But this would not be good to do, for nostalgia is deadly to true religion.
We must remember, or rather call to remembrance, on this Solemnity, the feast of the warrior angel, “he who is like God”, he who leads the charge against the forces of evil, he, who with the heavenly host still fight that war, even if silently, silently at least from our point of view. This is the time to remember that there is a war—no, not the wars that constantly rage in the world and have no end. We live in the time of in -between, the time of the Church on earth, of the not -yet, of the incomplete, the time when the real effects of the Cross and Resurrection of Christ are transforming the creation bit by bit, inevitably, but whose consummation is not yet, not yet. And even if we do not see the angels waging this war in our behalf. we do see around us the signs of what this war is about. The war is against those real and powerful forces in the world that not only deny the truth of the living God but also militate against that truth in so many ways. This is surely a religious war but it is a spiritual war. It is not a matter of jihad. It is much more subtle and dangerous. For the forces of the religion of secularism, a secularism that tolerates religious faith only in a closed off individualistic way, does not so much as to deny the existence of God but rather to banish Him from the discourse of the world. These forces are determined to conquer, and if one looks with realistic eyes, they have won important cultural battles that have weakened the real presence of the Christian faith in today’s culture.
All this image of war. Can this be congruent with the religion of peace? Of course it can and it must. Jesus said: “ I did not come to bring peace but a sword.” Conflict is part of being a follower of Jesus Christ, part of what it means to be a Christian. To deny this is to deny the Gospel and Church history. Charles Williams, a strange literary figure, Anglican by persuasion, says something in his idiosyncratic history of the Church to the effect that when the dogma of infallibility of the Pope was defined in that famous thunderstorm in Rome in 1870 by Blessed Pio Nono: he says that the Church regained her manhood. A wonderful phrase: her manhood. For what we are talking about here is virtus, a Latin word that is often translated only as “virtue” and thereby made harmless by the virus of moralism. But the root meaning of this word virtus is vir, the man as hero. On the feast of the Warrior Angel, the Prince of the heavenly host, we remember, or we should remember, that we are all called as Christians to show courage, which is the second meaning of virtus, that we are all called to be men and women of virtue, which is the third meaning of virtus: all three meanings bound to each other, all necessary for the task of the evangelization of the world.
To be a Christian is not for wimps, is not for religious couch potatoes who confuse Christian faith with Brady Bunch Catholicism. No. What is called for today is manly men who are faithful husbands and fathers. What is called for today are manly men who are faithful priests who have the courage to make the Cross of Christ as the center of their lives. What is called for today are women who have the true virtus of Mary, the Mother of God, of St. Catherine of Siena, of St. Teresa of Avila, of St. Birgitta, of Mother Cabrini.
Oxford spires are beautiful. Daises are lovely. But they have little to do with the saint we celebrate at this Mass today, Saint Michael, the Archangel, who is fighting the battle against the prince of darkness on our behalf. And for this we are grateful and for this we sing his praises. But we must remember that it is we, you and I, who must also join this battle, a battle that will be won by the love of God for us shone in the Cross of Jesus Christ. And the first step is what we do here today. In this Mass we remember and commemorate and there is made present that event that is the sign of the sure outcome of the triumph of God: the battle that was fought on the Tree of Life. And every time Mass is offered we strike a blow in the words: Hoc est enim corpus meum. These words make the powers of the world tremble, for these words do what they say, are what they say, and by their transformative power advance the battle for goodness, truth and beauty every time they are said. For they make present from eternity in this our time the love of the infinite God who loved us so much that he gave his only begotten Son to die so that we may live.
St. Michael the Archangel, pray for us.
Father Richard Gennaro Cipolla