Rorate Caeli
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Aguer. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Aguer. Sort by date Show all posts

"In black and white": Archbishop Aguer on tradition versus relativism


"In black and white": Archbishop Aguer on tradition versus relativism

Published at InfoCatólica on March 30, 2022. Translated for Rorate.

The title that heads this note does not refer to the cinema before the invention of technicolor, but to the astonishing criticism of current ecclesiastical officialdom that is directed against the members of the Church who love the great Catholic Tradition, and who recognize that homogeneity is what should characterize the development of ecclesial realities: dogma, liturgy, law, institutions. I have often quoted St. Vincent of Lerins and the formulas he coined in his Commonitory. Those realities can be expressed nove (in a new way), according to the cultural contexts of certain times and places; but in the deposit to be transmitted one cannot include nova, new things, novelties, which imply a heterogeneity with respect to the origins.
 

Nico Spuntoni: "Bergoglio's 'revenge' on Ratzinger: what's behind the appointment of 'Tucho' Fernández"

Nico Spuntoni
Il Giornale
July 9, 2023
(source in Italian)

Although the Roman Curia was not essential for him, Monsignor Víctor Manuel Fernández will lead its most important dicastery. Less than twenty years ago the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith was in the hands of Joseph Ratzinger, until six years ago in those of the trusted Gerhard Ludwig Müller. Now the former Holy Office will pass from the hands of moderate Jesuit Luis Francisco Ladaria Ferrer to those of the 60-year-old Argentine of the man whom they call in his homeland "beloved disciple" and "major interpreter" of Francis.

“The Pneumonia of the Church”: Archbishop Aguer on the Sickness and Its Remedy

Archbishop Emeritus Hector Aguer

The title of this note comes from an eloquent image used by the African Cardinal Robert Sarah, who was Prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments—and who was “mercifully” retired from the Roman Curia, as soon as was possible without causing too much of a scandal. His Eminence, author of books of rare theological depth and spiritual dimension, compared the current disastrous situation of the Catholic Church with that which Pius X had to face: modernism, which Pope Sarto described and condemned in the encyclical Pascendi Dominici Gregis and the decree Lamentabili Sane Exitu. Compared to the current remains of the post-conciliar period, that was a mere cold. I dare to project this image: the Church today is suffering from severe pneumonia. I turn to an analysis of the symptoms.

 

At present—at least according to what is determined ex auctoritate superiori—there is neither kerygma nor didache in the Church. There remain, undoubtedly, survivors of better times, the pontificates of John Paul II and Benedict XVI. But in the “official” line, those who are outside the Church are no longer called to conversion, nor are the faithful who need and wish to grow in the Faith. Fundamental themes of the Creed and Catholic catechesis have disappeared from ordinary preaching: God in his Unity and Trinity; Jesus Christ, true God and true man; Redemption; sin and grace; the Commandments (the sixth, especially, is a thing of the past); hope in eternal life; the devil and his wiles; the danger and threat of eternal damnation; and, in general, the content happily expressed in the Catechism of the Catholic Church.

 

We can expect and find these truths in the preaching of Protestant evangelical pastors, who are not ashamed to show that they are Christians and zealously propose the way of following the Lord. We must excuse them for a certain fundamentalism in the interpretation of Sacred Scripture, which they know inside-out, and, in some cases, for a charismatic exultation that is a bit overwhelming. But, thanks be to God, these Christian brothers and sisters do proclaim something of the message of the Kingdom (what a pity that they have neither the Eucharist nor the Virgin Mary!). They exercise their ministry through programs in the media, which the Catholic Church in many places totally lacks. I do not know if there are many Catholics who actually turn to Protestant evangelicalism; what is certain is that the dimensions of the Church are shrinking in many countries, particularly in Argentina.

 

What, instead, is the dominant interest of Catholic preaching today, according to official guidelines? The “new paradigms”: improving people’s lives in this world; the care of Mother Earth; social injustices; “climate change”; the deforestation of the Amazon. In broad terms, we can say: the criteria of a New World Order, financed by the international imperialism of money. The Holy See yields; in February 2019 it adhered to the document on Universal Fraternity, signed in Abu Dhabi. Freemasonry rejoices.

 

Another symptom of pneumonia: the devastation of the liturgy that has followed the postconciliar debacle. The sensible recommendations contained in the constitution Sacrosanctum Concilium were not heeded. The itinerary followed by the reforms imposed by the Holy See—especially the creation of a new Mass, which is not usually called the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, but rather “Eucharistic celebration”—has failed to recognize that true reform is always a restoration. The eminent liturgist Klaus Gamber has shown how the rites of the Church developed organically, without ever breaking with Tradition. The recent pretension (it has been going on for half a century) implies a “creative pride,” with painful effects. If we wish to refer to the Roman Rite, we must recognize that it was substantially constituted at the end of the fourth century, by the work of Pope St. Damasus; it received additions by St. Gregory the Great at the end of the sixth century, and was defined after the Council of Trent by the Bull Quo Primum of St. Pius V. This is the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, the latest version of which is from 1962, the Missal of John XXIII. True reform is the recovery of the original forms, as St. Pius X did with the Gregorian Chant.

 

Benedict XVI knew very well that the traditional Latin Mass had never been abolished, and he reinstated it as an “extraordinary form” of the Roman Rite, in order to respect, with authentic pastoral sense, the priests who celebrated it and the faithful who participated in it with undeniable spiritual fruits. It was a very wise decision, as could be expected from a great theologian who is at the same time a man of God. This work was demolished by a draconian, despotic measure, the motu proprio Traditionis Custodes. This document was a lousy, arbitrary, and ideological ukase, alien to the organic development of the Church. Bishop Rob Mutsaerts has rightly written that “the Liturgy is not a plaything of the popes, but the heritage of the Church.”

 

The liturgical devastation is not acknowledged by the Holy See, which has embraced a flat, poorly-disguised progressivism. St. Vincent of Lérins, in his Commonitory, pointed out how doctrine, discipline, and in general all ecclesial realities develop homogeneously. This is how the truth can be expressed nove, with new, updated terms, but it cannot be replaced by nova, new things. In other words, the same dogma remains, with the same meaning, and the identity of the content of the Faith.

 

Relativism has almost officially imposed itself; we can no longer expect a clear definition of what to believe, and of the errors from which we must guard ourselves. We know this because, thanks be to God, we have the Catechism of the Catholic Church, a point of reference that frees us from the contradictions incurred by a “higher authority” on which the security of the faithful, especially the simplest, the poor, should be able to rest. Moreover, God, Christ, the Mystery of Redemption, the Church, the Mystical Body of Christ, seem to be trapped in the jaws of Kantian Practical Reason. Moralism takes the place of the dogma of Faith. There is much to be said about this aspect of the current problem, especially because it is a reductive morality that ignores the breadth of the Law of God.

 

Another symptom of the pneumonia is the change produced in the last nine years in the method of discernment. Two weights and two measures are used. All is granted for the partisans of progressivism, in its various variants (I say “partisans” because it is about a partial vision of the Christian reality), but not even justice is given to those who love the great Ecclesial Tradition and decide to abide by it in their personal life, and in the participation or in the leadership of the Christian community. The method of “discernment” evoked here is brutally expressed by General Juan Domingo Perón, three times president of Argentina: “For friends, everything; for enemies, not even justice.”

 

This is how we discover why there are “cancelled priests” (this phrase is already widely in circulation), eliminated from the list by the bishops who are clinging to the new Roman orientations. The episcopal conferences are the instrument to impose a uniformity according to which “fraternity” is, simply, a beautiful word to show off. Bishops who are consistent with all that the Apostolic Succession implies are ignored and abandoned to their fate. Episcopates are often instruments of ecclesial politicization. We can call “cancelled bishops” those who are liquidated before their time, without waiting for the guillotine of 75 years to arrive. It does not matter if the dioceses over which they preside are flourishing and they enjoy the love of the faithful; many times disloyalty, denunciations, internal conflicts, play a role in their downfall. And sincere objectivity is lacking for the correct judgment of such situations.

 

The habit of murmuring has often been attributed to women, but in reality it is a typically clerical vice. The bishops of Ciudad del Este (Paraguay) and San Luis (Argentina), among others, have been cancelled. Daniel Fernandez Torres, Bishop of Arecibo (Puerto Rico), was deposed because, with all dignity, he refused to resign as requested by the Apostolic Delegate. Three years ago I preached there the Spiritual Exercises to the clergy of the diocese; and I was able to verify, personally, what a well-conducted particular Church looks like. Will Bishop Dominique Rey, bishop of Fréjus-Toulon, who has just been ordered by Rome to suspend the ordinations of six deacons and four priests only three weeks before the scheduled date, be one of the next to be cancelled?

 

Faced with the panorama I have tried to describe, one can ask oneself what to do, what medicine to take, in order to cure this pneumonia. I answer: we have to cry out—not content ourselves with complaining to ecclesial officialdom, even if errors and injustices are noticed and suffered, but rather, cry out to God! In Sacred Scripture, especially in the prophetic books, we find numerous cases in which the people of Israel cried out to the Lord—their cry reached the ears of the Almighty and Merciful God, and He responded to those who prayed to Him with humility and trust in times of great distress. Many psalms contain such cries of the heart, especially individual and collective lamentations.

 

In the face of the persistent pneumonia affecting the Church, let us cry out to the heavenly Physician. Prayer becomes a cry whenever we fail to see any relief in the development of the disease; this cry must be sustained by an unwavering Faith. We believe that the divine answer can grant us a new stage of health and freshness, of gratitude and joy, to better fulfill the Lord’s command. In Isaiah 30:19, we read: “Yes, O people of Zion who dwell in Jerusalem, you shall weep no more. He will have mercy when he hears your cry; as soon as he hears you, he will answer you.”

 

A popular saying assures us that “no evil lasts a hundred years”; and in bad times it is not only necessary to bear with patience and serenity what the Lord allows for our good, but also to look to the future with hope. I am referring to theological virtue of hope, by which we “hang” on the Will of God, as we do when we pray the Our Father: Thy Will be done, on Earth as it is in Heaven.

 

+ Hector Aguer

Emeritus Archbishop of La Plata

Buenos Aires, Pentecost Tuesday, June 7, 2022

Archbp. Hector Aguer: The position of Francis and Fernandez is "absolutely contrary to the historical depth of the ecclesial care of the Faith"

Former heads of the DDF / CDF / Inquisition

Argentines in Rome

+ Hector Aguer
Archbishop Emeritus of La Plata
July 28, 2023

What a paradox! A country like Argentina, without currency, with an inclusive language imposed by the grammatical ignorance of politicians, and with unarmed forces -- that is, almost a non-country, according to the characterization of country offered by General De Gaulle -- has colonized papal Rome. The Supreme Pontiff is Argentine, and now so will be the Prefect of the most important Dicastery, that of the Doctrine of the Faith.

The letter from the Successor of Peter to his chosen one implicitly intends to redo the history of the former Holy Office. Fernández, the addressee, stated in declarations that "that name, or that of the Inquisition -- as it was also called -- is a bit scary, because it was a place of persecution of heretics; Pope Francis says that at times immoral methods were used, as a sort of intelligence and control and even at some point torture."

The first thing that comes to mind is that this very distant allusion forgets centuries of ecclesial history, and it halts before the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith led by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger -- later Benedict XVI -- during two decades of John Paul II's pontificate. Ratzinger is the author of monumental theological work, in the process of being published in full, and not a few books on spirituality. This work combines theological knowledge, philosophical penetration, asceticism and mysticism and a very broad culture. This reference to Ratzinger's personal work is appropriate, since it contains the genuine criteria for his performance as Prefect. The office includes the examination of the ideas disseminated, and the need to weigh what is disseminated in the Church in the light of her authoritative Tradition.

Archbishop Fernandez -- who until now was Archbishop of La Plata -- continues to transmit what Francis told him, which "is very clear. You have to take care of the teaching of the Church but not by controlling or persecuting, but by making it grow, deepening the reflections, trying to go to the depth of the subject. That makes us all grow. If there is a problem or someone is accused of having said something out of place, we talk about it and we talk about it."

The new Prefect also points out that the Pope's insistence that he accept the position "shows his enormous delicacy and the respect he has for people's consciences." According to these references, they ponder the "very great novelty," which would also be reflected in the next synod, in which "a multitude of themes will emerge because it is planned with an openness never seen before; it is a unique space where the Pope sits, not to lower the line, but to listen to the diversity of opinions and to try to reach some consensus." He continued: "There is a mission, and it is that I have to make sure that the things that are said are coherent with what Francis has taught us. He gave us a look, a broader understanding, and we cannot respond today the same way we responded 40 years ago."

I translate: there is absolute freedom for all the inventions and machinations; you just have to beware of the "backwardists" who stubbornly follow the ecclesial Tradition. To those with good understanding, this explains the meaning of the current pontifical ideology, according to which the papal monarchy persecutes and liquidates those who do not keep up with the doctrinal relativism professed by the Latin American (Argentinian, we should say) officialdom.

The position that I have outlined -- based on actual statements, which have been collected by the newspapers -- is absolutely contrary to the historical depth of the ecclesial care of the Faith, since the time of the Apostles. Even in times when the pontifical power was exercised by cretins, womanizers, worldly men, or victims of imperial meddling, it always took care that the Truth that Christ has entrusted to the Church not be sullied.

Let us review the apostolic teaching recorded in the New Testament. I limit myself to a single quotation: "I adjure you before God and Christ Jesus, who is to judge the living and the dead, and in the name of his Manifestation and his Kingdom: proclaim the Word of God, insist with occasion or without occasion, argue, reprove, exhort, with untiring patience and with eagerness to teach. For the time will come when men will no longer endure sound doctrine; on the contrary, carried away by their inclinations, they will seek out a multitude of teachers to flatter their ears, and will turn away from the truth to listen to fanciful things [the Greek text says myths]. You, on the other hand, watch carefully....." Thus wrote the Apostle Paul to his disciple Timothy (2 Tim 4:1-5).

The Fathers of the Church also fought against errors; in the first six centuries the catalogs of heresies multiplied, reproving them. Let us recall, for example, the Adversus haereses by St. Irenaeus of Lyons, the De haeresibus by St. Augustine, and other works of the same name by various authors. The Councils included in their decisions the condemnation of people who spread errors. It is a constant attitude. The duty is not only to deepen, enlighten, and spread the Truth; the Truth must be vindicated when it is undermined. This has always been done. And doing it requires vigilance. In the quotation from 2 Tm 4, 5 it is said, in Greek: sy de nēphe en pasin; it is a laborious and all-embracing occupation.

As an aside, I refer to a non-Catholic case. The philosopher of existence Soeren Kierkegaard, a Lutheran in continuous search of authentic Christianity, in his Diary, which occupies 19 volumes of his work, takes up this vigilance against the modern world and its errors, which imply the abolition of Christianity.

Argentines in Rome. In a recent commentary on the situation of our country, Francis has said that "we Argentines are the problem." Yes, but today we have colonized papal Rome! One last piece of news: the Supreme Pontiff has summoned a young Argentine priest to help him as his personal secretary.

"What an aggressive, paradoxical imitation of Christ!": Archbishop Hector Aguer

"Stupor" is the word that rises to my lips upon learning the contents of the 50 pages of the Instrumentum laboris, for the Synod that has been "democratically" programmed since 2021. La Prensa of Buenos Aires headlines the news as follows:

Analysis of motives behind Francis appointing Victor Manuel Fernandez to the Doctrine of the Faith

Caminante - Wanderer
Buenos Aires 
July 3, 2023

A few weeks ago, when we learned of the appointment of Archbishop García Cuerva as the new Archbishop of Buenos Aires, I commented in this blog that Pope Francis had already let go of Bishop Tucho Fernández's hand.

Op-Ed: With 'Traditionis custodes', Francis Promotes Disunity (by Archbishop Aguer, Emeritus of La Plata, Argentina)

 A Regrettable Step Backwards

Archbishop Héctor Aguer*
Emeritus of La Plata, Argentina
for Infocatólica


The current Pontiff declares that he wishes to pursue even further the constant search for ecclesial communion and to make this purpose effective, he eliminates the work of his predecessors by placing arbitrary limits and obstacles to what they established with intra-ecclesial ecumenical intention and respect for the freedom of priests and faithful! It promotes ecclesial communion in reverse. The new measures are a regrettable step backwards.


I was ordained a priest for the Archdiocese of Buenos Aires on November 25, 1972; I celebrated my first Mass the following day in the parish of San Isidro Labrador (Saavedra neighborhood), where I resided all that year, exercising the diaconate. Obviously I celebrated according to the Novus Ordo promulgated in 1970. I have never celebrated "the ancient Mass," not even after the motu proprio Summorum Pontificum; I would have to study the rite, of which I have distant memories, having served as an altar boy. Recently, while attending the Divine Liturgy of the Syrian Orthodox Church, I seemed to notice a certain resemblance to the Latin Solemn Mass, with deacon and subdeacon, in which I often assisted, especially at funerals, which in my parish were often celebrated with special solemnity. I insist: I have always celebrated, with the greatest devotion I can muster, the rite in force in the Universal Church. When I was Archbishop of La Plata, I used to sing the Eucharistic prayer in Latin every Saturday at the "St. Joseph" Major Seminary, using the precious Missal published by the Holy See. We had formed, according to the recommendation of the Second Vatican Council in the Constitution Sacrosanctum Concilium n. 114, a schola cantorum, which has been eliminated at my retirement. In Traditionis custodes (Art. 3§ 4) it speaks of a priest delegated by the bishop to be in charge of the celebrations of the Mass and the pastoral care of the faithful of the groups authorized to use the Missal prior to the reform of 1970. It is stated there that he "should have a knowledge of the Latin language". It should be remembered that it is possible to celebrate the Mass currently in force in the whole Church in Latin. The Council affirmed in Sacrosanctum Concilium 36 § 1, "The use of the Latin language in the Latin rites is to be preserved, except by special law." Unfortunately, the "particular right" seems to be to prohibit Latin, as in fact it is done (this is not a boutade). If someone dares to propose to celebrate in Latin, he is looked upon as a misguided, unforgivable troglodyte.

Latin was for centuries the bond of unity and communication in the Western Church. Today it is not only abandoned, but hated. In the seminaries its study is neglected, precisely because it is not useful. They do not realize that this closes off direct access to the Fathers of the Western Church, who are very important for theological studies: I am thinking, for example, of St. Augustine and St. Leo the Great, and of medieval authors such as St. Anselm and St. Bernard. This situation seems to me to be a sign of cultural poverty and willful ignorance.

“A permanent parliament in which Jesus Christ is no longer preached, conversion to Truth and Grace no longer called for”: Bishop Aguer on the Synod on Synodality

The Synodality of the Church
by Most Rev. Héctor Aguer
Archbishop Emeritus of La Plata, Argentina
January 21, 2022

The [preparatory phase of the] XVI session of the Synod of Bishops was recently inaugurated with a Mass in St. Peter’s Basilica [October 10, 2021].

“Casuistry or prudence?”—Article by Archbishop Aguer

Argentina’s political and social problems are multiplying and causing concern and anguish; they would provide an argument for a long exposition. However, I prefer to deal with an ecclesiastical issue, which I consider must be clarified in no uncertain terms.

“Deconsecrated Temples and the Religion of Man” — Archbishop Hector Aguer

In recent times, we have witnessed, here and there, the use of cathedrals and other sacred buildings for conferences and other events for politicians, social leaders and members of other groups of different orientations. In this way, for example, recognition is sought for the ten years since the pontifical election. And the Pope himself endorses them with words such as: "It comforts my soul that my person has made possible this moment of communion, of encounter beyond differences." In these meetings, the Holy Father's teachings in the encyclicals Laudato Si and Fratelli Tutti are invited to be taken up.

“Secure in the faith, despite Rome”—Archbishop Hector Aguer

The persistence of the maximum exponent of today's ecclesial magisterium in criticizing—sometimes mockingly—those who are sure of the identity of the faith and joyfully affirm themselves in it, grateful to God for being rooted in the great Tradition of the Church, is a cause of astonishment, bewilderment, and concern for many of the faithful. These faithful Christians are reviled as rigorous Pharisees. The unusual position of the Holy See at this time contradicts the teaching of St. John Paul II and Benedict XVI, who so loved and glorified the splendor of truth (veritatis splendor). The relativistic moralism currently professed by Rome sinks the reality of faith and its ethical and spiritual consequences into the Kantian realm of practical Reason.

Worse still: the "new paradigms" proposed by the current pontificate submit to the dictates of a New World Order, managed by Freemasonry and financed by the international imperialism of money. It has long been known that the Vatican is a hive of Freemasons, who help each other to climb to the most influential positions, according to the secret pacts that have characterized the sect from its origins, pacts that have been repeatedly denounced by the pontiffs who warned about the danger this long-time enemy of Holy Church implies for the social order based on natural law, and for the support and development of the faith in the life of the peoples. I am aware of the truth and accuracy of what I have just written, so I do not fear that my freedom will be curtailed by measures that no one will dare to take.

Errors and heresies can be initiated and widely propagated in the face of the complicit silence of those who should, as has been done since apostolic times, condemn them. The testimony of the New Testament is eloquent: "It is fitting that there should be heresies, so that it may be made manifest who are faithful" (1 Cor 11:19: hina kai hoi dokimoi phaneroi genōntai). The German synod, in the face of Rome's silence, plainly distinguishes within that Germanic people the true believers from those trapped by errors, which should make Martin Luther smile (wherever he is). In the same letter we quoted, the Apostle Paul reminds the faithful of the Gospel he preached to them, the one they received, in which we stand firm (estēkate: 1 Cor 15:1), by which they are saved, if they stand firm (ei katechete: 1 Cor 15:2), because otherwise they have believed in vain (ektos ei mē eikē episteusate). The fundamental thing, Paul reminds them, is what he has delivered to them. It is scandalous that Rome disqualifies tradition. St. Peter, in his Second Letter, notes to his readers—and to us!—that his purpose is to secure them, to make them more steadfast (estērigmenous, 2 Pet 1:12); he warns them against the lying teachers (pseudodididáskaloi) who are introduced into the Church, as were the false prophets among the people of Israel; by them the way of truth is blasphemed (2 Pet 2:2).

The pastoral epistles of the Apostle Paul describe a situation that has occurred periodically in the history of the Church: "perilous times" (kairoi chalepoi, 2 Tim. 3:1) are precipitated by the introduction of errors that weaken the faith and the security of the faithful with respect to the tradition on which they rely. That is why he encourages his disciples and co-workers to resist. Many times I have quoted the passage of 2 Tim. 4, 1ff.: the pastors of the Church must tirelessly preach the truth, they must argue and rebuke (epitimēson: 2 Tim. 4, 2). The problem was, and is, false teachers who flatter ears, seeking "relevance," seeking to relocate themselves in the wider world, indulging in myths, abandoning the truth (apo men tēs alētheias...epi de tous mythous, ib 4, 4). Similar to these texts are many other biblical passages in which the exact opposite of the orientation of the present pontificate is expressed. The contrast appears in the simple comparison.

I have pointed out one cause in the predominance of moralism, which strips the doctrine of faith of the dynamism that directs it toward its mystical dimension. Faith is contemplative; its application to action depends on that fecund and sure repose in truth which is its object: it is theoria rather than praxis; and the latter knows what to do, in every circumstance, because it is illuminated by that higher light which allows us to discern with wisdom. Moralism is necessarily pragmatic and relativistic. The criticism I direct at the current that is nowadays official includes the observation that the doctrine of the faith is no longer preached in its entirety. St. John Paul II has left us in the Catechism of the Catholic Church an updated synthesis of what we must believe and spread today. In this corpus that embraces dogma, morals, and spirituality is found the identity of Catholicism, in which we Christians in this "dangerous time" can assure ourselves, directing the gaze of our spirit to the Lord who is with us "every day" (pasas tas hēmeras, Mt. 28:20).

It seems unbelievable—but it is a painful reality—that, after more than half a century, those words of Paul VI are still true: "Through some crack, the smoke of Satan has entered the House of God." The seductive "spirit of the Council," against which Jacques Maritain reacted so wisely in The Peasant of Garonne, appears again, this time from the Vatican Hill itself! The pontifical speeches expressly elude the truths that should be remembered with clarity, magnanimity, and patience, and dwell exclusively on those "new paradigms" that strike in vain those who are truly faithful, who try to live faithfully what they have received. The Christian is someone who has received what he believes and who, thanks to the sacraments of Penance and the Eucharist, tries to order his life as a new man according to the example of Christ.

It should not surprise us that the sacraments have no place in the pastoral programs encouraged by "synodality." Sacramentum translates the Greek mysterion; relativistic pragmatic moralism is incapable of perceiving the mysteries of faith, and spontaneously tends to discard the supernatural dimension in the pastoral care of the sacraments, which assures the gift of grace offered to all: liberation from sin and expansion of the new life of participation in the divine nature. We are partakers of the divine nature, theias koinōnoi physeōs (2 Pet. 1:4). What constitutes the life of a Christian is to remain in what he has received, in the "old commandment," which St. John says in his First Letter, the entolēn palaiàn (1 Jn 2:7), i.e., the reception of the light that drives away the darkness: hē skotia paragetai (1 Jn 2:8).

A historical fact that allows us to appreciate how far the "danger" of this dark time extends has been the silence, or perhaps the repudiation, that has greeted the respectful presentation of dubia about the scope of the semi-disguised innovation in the Exhortation Amoris Laetitia, the work namely of four eminent cardinals, Burke, Cafarra, Brandmüller, and Meisner. The question of the possibility of admitting to the sacraments divorced persons who have entered into a new union was a trial balloon of a relativist moralism for which there are no longer any intrinsically evil acts. It is a swindle against the same possible beneficiaries of that permission, with the purpose of tracing an alternative path to the one indicated by Tradition; it is an equivocation that cannot be considered a gesture of mercy.

Justice—justification by grace—is true mercy. The objectivity with which Eucharistic praxis is inscribed in the Christian life is no less important than the mere subjective desire to receive communion; in this order, Catholic Tradition, with the recognition of sound theology, is faithful to the origins that appear unequivocally in the New Testament. The security provided by embracing the truth known and loved in no way implies contempt for those who hesitate or have already been won over by relativism; on the contrary, it expresses the fraternal concern to make them participate in the joy offered by the integrity of the faith, humbly received as an undeserved gift.

The uneasiness provoked by the current position of the magisterium is aggravated when considering the system of promotions to the episcopate and to the cardinalatial dignity, because of their quantity and orientation. Indeed, what sense does it make for a diocese that lacks vocations and has an insufficient number of priests to meet pastoral needs to have two auxiliary bishops? I am referring to what is happening in Argentina, although the same attitude can be verified in other countries. It is not a sin of suspicion to think that there is an express purpose here to re-form the Church, and to spread the moralistic and relativistic criterion that, as I have already said, has become an official policy.

I would like to free myself from such concern and to be mistaken in the judgment I make of the orientation imposed from Rome. Like many others throughout the world who share this concern of mine, I can only rely on the trust and love of Christ, Lord and Spouse of the Church, and on the intercession of the Blessed Virgin, whom I invoke from my heart. I do not wish to fall into a pretentiousness of "being right" in my criticisms, even though the statements and the facts outlined above are a source of bitter pain for me, which prompt me to ponder and to judge.

May the Lord have mercy on us, and alleviate the duration of this "dangerous time" in which we live! I insist on what I observed at the beginning: astonishment, bewilderment, concern: what other feelings could be aroused by the strange spectacle of true Catholics being beat up while heretics are caressed? Our simple country people would say: "cosa 'e mandinga" ("devil's work"); the "smoke of Satan that has entered through a crack into the House of God," as a disenchanted Paul VI confessed.

Archbishop Hector Aguer
Buenos Aires
May 3, 2022

A Message to “Cancelled” Priests by Archbishop Héctor Aguer

To “Cancelled” Priests
Archbishop Héctor Aguer

“The anti-liturgical obsession is an ideology that canonically becomes a tyranny”: Archbishop Héctor Aguer

I celebrated my first Mass on November 26, 1972. I did it using the rite then in force, the one created by Paul VI, whose author was the Freemason Annibale Bugnini. The Mass was In Spanish, of course, though the secret prayers of the celebrant survived in Latin.

“To go back is to go forward, to be propelled by the river of the great Tradition”: Archbishop Aguer against Papal Progressivism

Progressivism, which established itself a decade ago in Rome, decries a kind of reverse populism.

The populist handbook indicates that one must win the trust and adhesion of young people. But it happens that young people nowadays are suspicious of deviations and progressive adventures; they prefer and love Tradition. Rome, then, scourges them by scornfully branding them as ones who would "go back to the past"; they look "back" and long to get "behind" [what came with Vatican II], which would be better than the present, better than the "progress" of the progressives. "Behind" are the roots, the Cenacle and the Cross, from which the great ecclesial Tradition springs.

It is interesting to note that young people in general have been enthusiastic about the possibility of participating in the Mass of Ages, as made possible, with great wisdom and pastoral zeal, by Benedict XVI, who established an "extraordinary form" of the Roman Rite, in 2007, through his motu proprio Summorum Pontificum. Undoubtedly, it was not only young people who since then adhered to the centuries-old celebration, in which they discovered the meaning of the Mystery; but, in particular, the new generations were dazzled by an accuracy, solemnity, and beauty that they never knew before, and that they did not find in the "Eucharistic celebration" invented by the Freemason Annibale Bugnini and his crew of specialists.

The motu proprio Traditionis Custodes was a real calamity, forcing many priests and faithful to disobedience, and treated with understanding (a kind of pardon) by the good bishops. This papal ukase, contrary to the much-vaunted synodality, has disavowed the work of the great pontiffs St. John Paul II and Benedict XVI. Tornare indietro [to go back], paradoxically, is equivalent to andare avanti [going forward], since it consists in adhering to the Tradition which is always the same, always new, not like a museum piece but rather like a living plant, as St. Vincent of Lerins perceived and said, in the 5th century: in eodem scilicet dogmate, eodem sensu, eademque sententia. The Pope is not the master of the liturgy, to do with it as he pleases, but its servant and custodian. Joseph Ratzinger explains this very well in his theology of the liturgy.

Besides criticizing "go-backism", Rome persists in criticizing those who use "very old-fashioned methods" -- another caricature of Tradition! It would be necessary to "renew our way of seeing reality, to evaluate it". It is also affirmed that "the only Council that some pastors remember better [than Vatican II] is that of Trent". It is said that this is not "nonsense"; well, it is worse: a fallacy, a mockery.

Another target of official progressivism is "restorationism", which it attributes to many in the United States; clearly, it is annoying that the great ecclesial Tradition flourishes in that country. The accusation is about a "restorationism that would not accept Vatican II". It is curious to see that Rome confuses the Council with the "spirit of the Council", which was its arbitrary deformation. The progressive mania considers as "signs of renewal" those groups "that give a new face to the Church through social or pastoral assistance". A new face in which Christ no longer recognizes that of his Bride!

The "go-backers" and "restorationists" are those who understand their action to be inspired from the constitution Sacrosanctum Concilium, a text in which the will of the Fathers of Vatican II decreed: "No one, even if he is a priest, may add, subtract or change anything on his own initiative in the liturgy" (n. 22). This indication implies that the liturgy is to be characterized by the exactness of the rite. In every religious system we encounter what the Roman jurist Pomponius Festus (who was a pagan) defined as mos comprobatus in administrandis sacrificiis. Joseph Ratzinger has interpreted this purpose as the "search for a just way of worshipping God, a form of prayer and communal worship pleasing to God that is in conformity with his nature. How to glorify him in such a way that this worship constitutes the right way to meet him. Mos means custom, manner, usage, practice, and also designates the law. In Christian language it is the rite, the 'orthodoxy', the legitimate glorification of God endorsed and sustained by the People of God, which is the Church".

The Roman Rite was formed in the first Christian centuries, and was transmitted unaltered. A vast number of saints celebrated it. In 2007, Benedict XVI rescued it as an "extraordinary form", and a multitude of young people discovered it as a perfect form of adoration of God, which makes present in a sacramental way the Sacrifice of the Cross.

Accuracy -- without subjectivist stiffness -- is an objective value in the Roman Rite, protects the adoration of the Mystery, and allows the union of the celebrant and the faithful with the supernatural reality that is made present under the veil of the sacramental signs. In the Eucharist God is truly glorified, and one participates in the Sacrifice of Jesus Christ, Incarnate Word and Risen Redeemer. In the new Mass of Paul VI (of Bugnini, in fact), the altar has disappeared, transformed into a table without a Cross; genuflections and reverences are omitted, and the celebrant looks at the faithful and refers to them in a fraternal encounter, instead of leading them to look with him to the East, to the rising Son, who comes so that, through the action of the Holy Spirit, the community of the Church may glorify the Father: with Christ, through Him and in Him, all honor and glory are given to the Father.

Two other values are attributed to the Rite that the "go-backers" and "restorationists" cultivate: solemnity and beauty.

Solemnity has been liquidated, in the practice of the new Mass, by trivialization; it is a smiling and friendly encounter in which the priest acts as animator. Eliminating ritual exactitude, special care is taken to create a "homely", everyday, ordinary atmosphere. In this way, the aim is to attract crowds, without realizing that solemnity is the guardian of the Faith, an invaluable gift of God, and that the Eucharist is a feast of the Faith.

By beauty we mean not only the setting, which must be artfully arranged, but the whole, the totality, and its perfection. Only one aspect should be emphasized: the music. The Gregorian plainchant and polyphony performed "a cappella", and the pipe organ, are replaced by the guitar, not played like a zither (note the kinship between guitar and zither) but badly played, punished one might say. The text and the elementary and percussive melody make up an insignificant ditty, with no musical or cultural value whatsoever.

The Roman Rite has given rise to creations of a superior art, which spread and became famous in the secular sphere. The greatest composers of the West, in the seventeenth century, offered the Church and the world a marvelous treasure. It is impossible in the dimensions of an article to collect the names that make up a famous list of authors of Masses, oratorios, hymns, and pieces of religious inspiration. By way of example: from Bach's Mass in B minor to Olivier Messiaen's Twenty Views of the Child Jesus. This musical wealth at the service of the Church was clearly popular. In the cities and even in villages, with modest means, the beauty of worship was always cultivated. A healthy "go-backism" can today put this treasure back into circulation, even outside of the liturgical celebration, presenting the compositions in the churches in a context of prayer. It is opportune to recognize that one prays not only by saying or singing, but also by listening, listening with the ears and with the heart. The fecundity of the Church has promoted musical creation and has exercised for centuries a patronage that should be recognized (and is recognized by historians), and that can be renewed for the glory of God and the education of the people. I insist: the beauty of worship can become popular if it is officially cultivated, if it once again finds a necessary place in the liturgy. There is nothing less popular than populism. Rome remains the center of the West; it does not suit her to adopt the pauperism of a distant republic.

The values of accuracy, solemnity, and beauty, if cultivated in the liturgy, leave a cultural imprint that constitutes a richness of evangelization. An objective reading, without ideological prejudices, of the constitution Sacrosanctum Concilium shows the coherence of Vatican II with the great ecclesial Tradition. A very different thing is the reform of the rites, especially the rite of the Mass, the work of Bugnini and his staff. Sectors of the Liturgical Movement, colored with rationalism, have not perceived the popular rootedness of the best achievements of the centuries-old practice concretized in the Mass, which has always manifested the unity of the Church.

I include at this point of reflection a long quote from Joseph Ratzinger/Benedict XVI, which expresses what I am trying to say:

A Mass celebrated in a village in Upper Bavaria would appear very different from a solemn Mass in a French cathedral, and this in turn from a Mass in a parish in southern Italy, or in a mountain village in the Andes, and so on. The ornamentation and the arrangement of the altar, as well as of the whole Church, the liturgical service, the way of singing and praying, all this gave the liturgy a particular physiognomy, so that one felt completely 'at home' in it.  And yet it could be experienced everywhere as one and the same, thus perceiving the great community of the Faith. The unity of the rite gives the real experience of the communio; where this is respected and at the same time encouraged, there is no contrast between multiplicity and unity.

The "go-backers" and "restorationists" only want to feel "at home" when they go to Mass. Tornare indietro is, in reality, andare avanti -- to go back is to go forward, to be propelled by the river of the great Tradition. To restore is to reconstruct, to rebuild, to rebuild the way always in force. There is no dead, smelly past, like Lazarus after four days in the tomb; it is something living, present, perennial, that we have to transmit to the future. This is the novelty and youth of Christianity. Rome now repudiates, in interventions that cause great confusion because of their deliberate ambiguity, the use of what it calls "very old-fashioned methods", and proposes "to renew our way of seeing reality, of evaluating it". This proposal of fundamental progressivism will only increase the number of "go-backers" and "restorationists", since Christian common sense itself invites us to adhere to those healthy positions.

 + Héctor Aguer
Archbishop Emeritus of La Plata
Buenos Aires, Monday, July 18, 2022

“Episcopal Conference? Freedom for the Bishops!” — Article by Archbishop Aguer — strong words on Bishop Daniel Fernandez Torres

On other occasions I have criticized the current centralized ecclesiastical organization, whose key piece is the local protagonism of the Episcopal Conferences. These have assumed a political role, imitating secular parliaments. There is, in general, a Presidency and two Vice-Presidencies, elected by a majority vote of the members of the Conference. There are no formally constituted episcopal parties, but there is no lack of groups that bring together those who share a certain ecclesiology, and the same opinion on intra-ecclesial issues as well as on social and political issues of the country; undoubtedly linked to Catholic morality and the Social Doctrine of the Church.

"Approaches to Ecclesial Radiography" - Archbishop Héctor Aguer

What do we see when we apply an x-ray to the body of the Church on earth? The emeritus Archbishop of La Plata, Argentina, tells us in this latest column from October 31, 2023. Translated for Rorate Caeli.

“Progressive Manias”: Powerful article by Archbishop Aguer

What is progressivism? I am referring to ecclesiastical progressivism, which, like secular progressivism, looks to the future as if the world and the Church were on the move, always evolving towards the best.

We could consider evolutionism as a sort of eponym of religious progressivism. This constitutes a system of “advanced” ideas and attitudes, which proudly detaches itself from any adherence to Tradition. The so-called modernism of the early twentieth century was described and condemned by St. Pius X in the Encyclical Pascendi dominici gregis and the Decree Lamentabili sane exitu. It brought together a Kantian (rationalist) philosophy, which repudiated Aristotelian-Thomistic thought; the “positive” studies of Sacred Scripture of a Protestant-liberal origin; and the desire to equate Christian culture with that which reigned in a Europe shaped by the revolutions of the 19th century, which had their roots in the French Revolution of 1789 and its Enlightenment. Modernists suffered from a kind of discomfort, as if they were alien or had been left out of what the Modern Age was proposing. Moreover, confusion reigned in modernism between the doctrine, its contents, and the modes of expression. In this regard, post-conciliar progressivism surpasses it by far.

Facing God, Rooted in Christ: The Latin Mass, Tradition, and Orthodoxy - by Abp. Agüer

Facing God, Rooted in Christ: On Tradition and Orthodoxy


By Archbishop Héctor Aguer
 Emeritus of La Plata, Argentina 
Buenos Aires, Monday, July 13, 2026



The always remembered Pope Benedict XVI — whom it is quite possible will one day be declared a Doctor of the Church — sought, through his Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum of July 7, 2007, on the two uses of the one Roman Rite in its ordinary and extraordinary forms, to liberalize the celebration of the Mass commonly called "traditional," "Tridentine," "of Saint Pius V," or "the Mass of all time." He did so with the aim of contributing to liturgical peace and out of the respect owed to an ancient and venerable usage. In this way, any priest could celebrate the "Latin Mass" without need of special permissions and without risk of ideologically motivated reprisals from certain bishops.

Roman rumors

The hyper-"Progressive" French religious weekly Golias mentions several possible changes in the Roman Curia after the probable nomination of Cardinal Canizares Llovera as the new Prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the eventual nomination of the current Secretary of the same Congregation, Archbishop Malcolm Ranjith, as the new Archbishop of Colombo, Sri Lanka. The list of possible replacements of Archbishop Ranjith includes Monsignor Nicola Bux, Father Joseph Augustine DiNoia, OP, undersecretary at the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, and Dom Gregor Henckel-Donnermarck,  abbot at Heiligenkreuz, Austria.

Golias also mention a possible substitution of Archbishop Piero Marini's friend at the helm of the Cappella Musicale Pontificia Sistina, Monsignor Fortunato Baldelli. Baldelli, Cardinal Mastinez Sistach (of Barcelona), and Archbishop Martin (of Dublin) could be named to less important Curial positions which would make their current positions available for new papal appointments. 

The well-known rumor of an early retirement of Cardinal Levada as head of CDF is once again mentioned as possible; his substitute could well be the Cardinal-Archbishop of Vienna, or even Cardinal Grocholewsky (current Prefect of Education) or Archbishop Hector Aguer, of La Plata, Argentina - predictably criticized by Golias, but considered by many a rare shining light within the Latin American episcopate.

________________
Tip: Le Forum Catholique

The Traditional Mass, Recovered — and The Power of Tradition - Op-Ed by Abp. Hector Aguer

 The Recovery of the Mass



by Archbishop Héctor Agüer
Emeritus of La Plata, Argentina 
June 1st, 2026


The media and, especially, social networks point out that in several European countries, particularly among young people, the "Traditional Mass" is being lived with fervor, accompanied by numerous processions and pilgrimages. The youthful crowds that revived the traditional Paris - Chartres pilgrimage have drawn widespread attention, with an average age of 22. It is a recovery of Catholic tradition, which had been suffocated in those countries by liberalism, progressivism, and atheism.